Dovina
on I've thought a lot by MacFrantic
4 Oct 2006, 9:39 AM
Yes, I'm hearing you! And seeing through a little more shadow toward what I cannot see. To aim at communication in poetry is to aim too low. To think we know what to aim for is the silliness of a child as seen by an adult.
Oh, they will tell you you are telling, not showing. Let them rant. This is good!
It's much stronger after the edit. I feel, now, that her leading him on is worse than lemon peel pinched in the eye, whereas before I wasn't sure. Something about making it perrsonal brings home the message.
i'll think on this. btw, i took another look at your poem about noah.
what did you intend here? i'm guessing you wanted to discuss the your own sense of doubt through noah's story. if that's the case, i'd suggest completely redoing the first stanza, which is far and away the weakest of the four. give your readers credit for possibly knowing the story of noah already, and use that space to form the question that the final three stanzas answer.
Perhaps end it by saying what the lie was or at least some hint to make the poem personal and less all-encompassing.
yeah, I think it needs another look. Thanks.
the heart of this poem is clever and insightful, but i think it needs a lot of work around the edges. the beginning and end read like what someone might teach in a creative writing class, while the middle, even though you're quoting someone else through most of it, feels by its cadence and arrangement like it truly contains your own voice.
the last stanza to me seems unnecessary, trying to spell out details of an emotion that could easily be implied simply by reversing the order of "nailed and forgiven." likewise the first stanza weakens the poem, makes it prosaic by introducing the subject in a story format rather than just jumping right in and adding any necessary details of the setting within the body of the text.
good eye. how would it read to you if i just eliminated the whole segment in-between "pinched in the eye" and the final stanza. it's sort-of an eyesore anyway (pardon the pun).
right now that's the best idea i can come up with, but other ideas are welcome.
hm, that strophe does seem to be a weakness. i'll have to think about how i might begin to concoct a remedy.
Intersting .. A couple of things that contradict, which has been pointed out already. Apart from that I think its pretty darn good.
Could be the start (or end) of a longer piece and I'd like to see you expand onthe theme.
Thanks Dovina !
I see what you were after and you're close. The firt line starts it off great. I remember a poem by Leanord Cohen in which there was a line describing a positive sensation as "...singing in the wires of my spine". This is something like you're after with the skeins, but in your case in a negetive way.
Dig for some other word/phrase choices on this. "crawling" under the skin? "Inching" Not sure.
poem is a good example of how important every singel word is.
Yes, if we could figure it all out, we would be like God. Of course, some people already have, and they have the greater faith. The rest of us rely on hope. Welcome to Poemranker.
im not a poet really i have never even read a real poem i just like to write and i hoped people would enjoy it thanks for your comments!!!
Neat, very astute too. A bit awkward at 'that lemon was loaded' - Led Zeppelin connotations there take it in a different direction to what I think you mean. I doubt many other people will see it in the same way though.
If we could figure it ALL by ourselves ,Hope would lose its meaning !
I like this down through "pinched in the eye." Then it loses momentum. Maybe lose "at her direction." And "was mild" is, well, mild. Otherwise good.