poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 67321–67340 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

some deleted user on love by flatliner 21 Aug 2002, 8:16 AM
It is hard for a reader to take in a poem that has such a broad, almost overwhelming title. You lose half your audience from people going, "Oh, god, another poem called 'Love'." Maybe you should reevaluate your intentions and try to show the reader what you are thinking rather than simply making a statement that could easily be said by anyone.
some deleted user on These things that we bury by Jody Conn 21 Aug 2002, 8:10 AM
You should avoid titling a poem and then using it as the first line. Just start the poem with the title. The idea behind this is sound, but the wording of the draft (although packed with some fair images) is a bit youthful. The rhetorical questions also weaken the structure. If you want the reader to participate in the poem, it is often a good idea to do it without asking. You might really hone in your idea and try to find the solid lines in the poem and begin working from there.
some deleted user on melancholy: by Sapphire 21 Aug 2002, 8:03 AM
I like the "languid lazy days," but the poems rhyme, along with the other, weaker images (i.e. ache of emptiness, grip/soul) ultimately tie the poem down in cliche.
keatsImnot on Black Buns by Bachus 21 Aug 2002, 7:04 AM
I thought the Home of the Whopper line penile reference
Christof on Making Sense in Plain Living by Flaithri 21 Aug 2002, 6:34 AM
I didn't really understand the title and this sounds more like prose than poetry
Christof on Hunny by Venus 21 Aug 2002, 6:21 AM
I think this is great - Sylvia Plath drops the Nazi imagery and gets her own back. How could any man neglect his Venus so thoughtlessly?
memorybabe on American Haiku 2 by memorybabe 21 Aug 2002, 5:05 AM
American just indicates the fact that it could never be a true Haiku because of the language. American also because this is about someone's trip across country.
Christof on A Nightmare by Dreamer 21 Aug 2002, 4:07 AM
This is rather melodramatic - I'd really get rid of the aposiopoesis at the end.
Dreamer on Northern Ireland by longships 21 Aug 2002, 3:55 AM
I really like this poem. You portray the situation brilliantly and also the frustration at not being able to conceive such inhumanity. See "The Curse". It is along the same lines, sort of!
god'swife on Belongings by Christof 21 Aug 2002, 3:21 AM
see, I knew it! She owned it, she drank it, that's some sexy sh*t. You can write, so don't take it personally if I think one of your poems isn't of this higher quality. By the way you can look up my drivel and shred it to pieces, as long as you're being honest. I'd appreciate that.
I love this poem it is witty and depressing and honest and real and full of grace. If it were my poem which clearly it is not, I would try to find a better phrasing for the last thought. it sort of disappoints.Kinda like oatmeal after chocolate mousse. Also,did the dead guy lose too, or did ashcroft lose to the dead guy?
This is just trying too hard to be clever and iconoclastic. I know what you mean but...if you sat next to me on the bus and launched into this, I'd move away.
I was determined to be annoyed by your stuff as you keep telling em to edit my work in an irritating high-handed manner but... bugger it, I think this is really great. Your self-denying but defiant last stanza breaks the heart.
Christof on North by lw_nd 21 Aug 2002, 1:31 AM
Regret and yearning so often live togetherI especially like the astrological stuff in the last stanza - as if this is what we're all fated to suffer. Existentialist, huh?
Christof on white harvest by <~> 21 Aug 2002, 1:19 AM
I love the first line, and the deceptive way the poem leads you to think it's going to be about more than an unwillingness to pay bills. It's something we can all understand and it's become heroic! Though I must admit I rifle through my post as soon as it comes in case someone's sent me an impromptu present. They never have.
some deleted user on Shelter by poetandknowit 21 Aug 2002, 12:35 AM
Oh, by the way, your poetry fucking sucks. Just thought I'd let you know. I really tried to like it, I really did...
Jarah on You strike me by Butterflies 21 Aug 2002, 12:33 AM
I dont care what other people think but i think ur poem was kewl, from the heart.. not many people care about that stuff.. so we gotta get out there and tell them how we dont care about their gay verses.. lol ':-)
poetandknowit on Shelter by poetandknowit 21 Aug 2002, 12:23 AM
I wish I could say somewhere other than Misery, but KC (born and raised til 17) is it. I have lived a ton of places, (Montreal being the favorite), but I am back here for the time being. At least I travel a good deal. You? Deal! Ah!! I am off to get my fax. Until tomorrow.
<~> on Shelter by poetandknowit 21 Aug 2002, 12:17 AM
i'll only trash it if it's shaped like colorado. deal?
<~> on Shelter by poetandknowit 21 Aug 2002, 12:15 AM
ah, the moment of clarity, arriving too late. as you said, at least it's getting wrapped up. as much as i like a nice drinkie with friends, things have been known to out themselves in the most uncomfortable of ways on those occasions. sigh. so, where're you from, originally?