MacFrantic
replying on Or Outward by MacFrantic
9 Apr 2006, 6:27 PM
Visual rhythm. I didn't want the aesthetics of the poem to be thrown off even a little bit. I had to sacrifice a bit of grammar to do so. Last I checked, intentional grammar flaws aren't frowned upon.
Most recently, discussing April Fools's Day.
Oh. Okay. Then what have you been doing your last half-dozen posts?
I do not mean to bring spiritual experience into it either. On that I agree with him.
Then why not leave him out of this part? He'd be the first to admit that spiritual experience is not his territory, beyond the suggestion that it's probably and most-simply a psychological phenomenon.
At least he admits it!
That's his opinion. Mine is that I may consider reasons for our existence beyond our own minds, beyond psychology.
Um, I do. Because he's only relevant in the way I've already pointed out. Namely, that asking "why are we here?" is a psychological phenomenon, roughly equivalent with having dreams about possessing a bold black moustache.
I grant you permission to ask. But I see no reason to omit his opoinions.
Oh. Well I'd like to ask that you don't mention him anymore in this context. He's only relevant in the way I've already pointed out.
Don't be silly. I know why I'm in Alaska. I also know (as well as anyone knows) why I'm a human being on the planet Earth in 2006. The desire for "a reason" for existence presumes God. You shouldn't be so surprised at finding God at the end of that goose-hunt.
So we and everything else are here for no good reason. I see. Considering the miserable places you've got yourself into in the last couple years, maybe you should start asking that question. The scorching desert and in subzero Alaska.
I did not abuse Occam, I simply mean something different, when I ask, "why are we here?"
NOTE: Occam says the question "why are we here?" is likely just a psychological phenomenon and a result of our explainable, evolutionary, question-asking tendencies. If you're going to abuse Occam, at least abuse him right.
Now carry on with your nonsense.
I want the poem to march along with the pounding waves, but I don't want it to rhyme. I think rhyming could give it a sing-song sound, not in keeping with a battle. Thanks for the comment though.
Now that zodiac has stepped aside, allow me to take up the question, âWhy are we here?â which I have asked many times. My childhood answer was simple â because God put us here for His pleasure. Occam says my childhood answer is simple and satisfying, but that it may not be true in view of other answers that science may someday provide. If that is true, there may be no reason for our being here other than the result of nature, however that comes to be known.
For me to ask why I am here is like a chicken asking why it is in a cage, provided with all it needs until its timely death. That answer is in the mind of intelligence the chicken cannot comprehend. Likewise, if we are here for a reason, it is beyond our ability to understand, unless our maker decides to tell.
Semaphores.
Oh, I see. I've never in my life asked the question "Why are we here?" so I'm probably not the one to talk about this with.
Some folks are stubborn donkeys that just stand there and don't care and others are kicking at the carrot dangler with their hind legs to spite him. I won't name names though.
Guess I missed that one. See my comment there.