poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 9301–9320 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

Dovina replying on Numbers In Heaven by Dovina 13 Mar 2006, 6:11 PM
Oh, now I see what you're saying in an achemist's way: "All numbers are junk. Only as a number represents a quantity of something or the nth something, is the number unique." And of course that's the post-Russell view. But I'm using the concept of "numbers as intrinsic entities" as a metaphor and also because they're cute little buggers. 183 even has personality, feminity and gall. I think you take as a position-paper something I intend to be about human nature. And admittedly, I've poured in some numerical mystique into this gold-making experament.
ALChemy replying on Numbers In Heaven by Dovina 13 Mar 2006, 5:54 PM
How is 183 any different than say 69 when you already stated any odd number will due. Are there other only slightly different Dovina clones running around with different odd numbered names? 183 is only unique in it's abstract form as a meaningless number. Once you attach it to something, let's say 183 apples, then it becomes a statement of how many of the same thing are in a group. Apple 183 must have something in common with apple 182 and so on, otherwise they wouldn't be grouped and numbered. Sure you could say each apple is different but you can say that about any two things at least at a quantum level. The point is you count things based on simularities. If 183 is you it's not unique because there's at least 184 of you according to your poem. If 183 is just a number then it has no reason to be in this poem so it's junk.
zodiac replying on Numbers In Heaven by Dovina 13 Mar 2006, 5:37 PM
In short, you are a prize loon. You can't even say what part of numbers you find so exciting and eternal, so I'm going to help you. Here are the possibilities: 1) The symbols and sounds themselves. That is, first you make a w, then a schwa, then a n, and you have 'one'. Or you make a straight vertical line, possibly with a little cap - 1. Well, that's just clodly. Obviously, if every English speaker died or forgot English, there would be no "one" or "1". There would just be "uno", "waHad", ")" or any of a million things. You can't be talking about that. 2) The values themselves. How, in a universe with no intelligent life, you could have a plum and another plum, and you, Dovina, showing up from our universe can say, "Look, a plum and a plum - two plums!", just like in our universe. So then you're not really talking about the independent existence of numbers or number-symbols; you're just talking about the independent existence of OBJECTS: the plums continue to exist even if no one's there to see them. So why don't you just say that? Oh, because numbers are magic. And you're a clod. If you're not, you can't possibly be talking about that. 3) How numbers, the things we call 1, 2, 3, and so on, perfectly correspond to whole objects. Well, obviously. and we have names for all the things that don't correspond to whole objects, like pi, e, or 9.126923683427. For obvious reasons, we've used the shorter symbols to refer to whole things, since we're more likely to be talking about whole eggs or goats. Is that what's so magical? That we made up a short symbol for something we talk about regularly? Then you are a loon. 4) Plato was actually talking about how circles and spheres not only EXIST outside human consciousness, but that they're BEAUTIFUL and PERFECT outside human consciousness. Like, if all humans died and another intelligent species came along millennia later and made a sphere, it would think spheres are the acest shape, too. And gold. They'd think gold was the best substance, because it's, like, God's substance, and God's not going to let anyone forget about it. Do you see how this can't possibly be what you're talking about, rambling about perfect 183? Do you see how, if it is, you're the not-brightest person ever?
BenRice replying on Stella 130 by BenRice 13 Mar 2006, 5:27 PM
For both Ranger and Dovina: This was more something to amuse my wife. We had been looking at Shakespeare's sonnets to be read at our wedding. I thought I'd amuse her one day with my take on Sonnet 130. Some of it is hardly "poetic", but then, neither is my dog. So, you're right, it's something that could be more than an amusement if I spent some time on it. But really, any promise it shows is probably because I ripped it off from Bill. (Yes I just called him Bill. Is that super-pretentious?)
BenRice replying on Stella 130 by BenRice 13 Mar 2006, 5:21 PM
Yay, someone recognized it for what it is, just a fun little take on 130. You're right about the more original language. I need to sit with this one a lot longer to make it into something that isn't so trite. The execution of the iambic pentameter., or lack thereof, irks me. And the apostrophe... well, that was just stupidity. Btw, thanks. I didn't know I had been missed. :)
zodiac replying on Numbers In Heaven by Dovina 13 Mar 2006, 5:14 PM
I mean, every symbol or word we use for describing quantity describes one unique real-world value? Yes. So? If it didn't, if the word "seven", say, applied to two different values, that would be kind of stupid, wouldn't it? You'd tell your wife or husband to pick up seven eggs and he wouldn't know how many to get. People would probably start referring to the lower "seven" as "little seven" and the higher seven as "big seven". And people like you would stupidly think "little seven" was a magical eternal thing. bow'ls.
zodiac replying on Numbers In Heaven by Dovina 13 Mar 2006, 4:59 PM
If I remember correctly, you don't believe in the intrinsic values of THINGS (ie, gold), only numbers. How odd. Or dumb. I'm sure I don't care which.
zodiac replying on Numbers In Heaven by Dovina 13 Mar 2006, 4:54 PM
If you had never existed, would there still be a Platonic, eternal Dovina floating around somewhere? Where?
zodiac replying on Numbers In Heaven by Dovina 13 Mar 2006, 4:52 PM
Reality doesn't shift. Say we've got gravity, and we've got a formula that calculates the gravity to masses exert on each other. Suppose we find out that, um, at really large masses (or on the infamous quantum level) the formula doesn't work. Something different happens. That doesn't mean reality's changed, or even gravity; just that the formula was wrong under certain circumstances. Gravity (and quantum mechanics) have probably always worked the same, we just didn't know. No right-minded mathematician has a problem with that.
Dovina replying on Numbers In Heaven by Dovina 13 Mar 2006, 4:06 PM
What could you possibly mean? This is bunk! Every number is unique - that's obvious. and I KNOW what I am talking about, because I am 183 and proud.
ALChemy replying on Numbers In Heaven by Dovina 13 Mar 2006, 3:58 PM
183 is junk too. You stated 183 could be an odd number for all that it matters. So how can you expect us to think it's unique? Oh let's see, maybe 183 is just a name lik Bob. Well then why is Bob nestled between 2 evens? Of course the number 183 is nestled between 2 evens and presumably will be eternally. That's the statement you made in your poem and let's admit it's quite an obvious statement. So you didn't need to tell us that, hence it's junk. I actually thought 183 was a star at first. That metaphor would have worked great but then 183 wouldn't be eternal. Maybe you should take some advice from faithmairee and write a little more about what you know. I still think it's a great idea but I think you took the metaphor a little too far.
Ranger replying on Desolation by Beyond_Dreams 13 Mar 2006, 3:45 PM
Having never hailed Green Day or U2 I think I get away with my lambasting...besides, I was polite, wasn't I?
Dark Angle replying on Desolation by Beyond_Dreams 13 Mar 2006, 3:42 PM
what always bothers me is that when Green Day or U2 does it they are hailed as prolific artists with vision and great depth but when some Joe Everybody does it they are lamblasted as charlatans of the world of words.
Dark Angle on =, <>, & . . . by Dovina 13 Mar 2006, 3:35 PM
i would vote this a ~`&* but that option isnt available so a 7 will have to suffice.
Dark Angle on Numbers In Heaven by Dovina 13 Mar 2006, 3:34 PM
were you a math major in college?
Ranger replying on Numbers In Heaven by Dovina 13 Mar 2006, 3:18 PM
Oh, I doubt it's the 'new thing'...but as I said, it reminded me of The Island (minus Ewan MacGregor's dubious accent...there's none of that in here, fortunately). Have a watch sometime and see if what I said makes sense. If it doesn't, well I don't even know what I'm typing sometimes, so don't worry about it.
Dark Angle on Settling in by INTRANSIT 13 Mar 2006, 3:16 PM
consider yourself part of the furniture
Dark Angle on By Request by thepinkbunnyofdoom 13 Mar 2006, 3:12 PM
very self referencial of this poem to self reference as it does so.
Dovina on Settling in by INTRANSIT 13 Mar 2006, 3:11 PM
A good bed-time read until I come to emotional responses in your fixtures, "in approval" or "adoringly." I'm not sure I like a snooping floor.
INTRANSIT replying on Numbers In Heaven by Dovina 13 Mar 2006, 3:05 PM
I've got no college or formal training in these things and it makes me think I'm missing out on something really important. Then comes a small woman in a bonnet with a gentle smile, and all is right again. Poems (topics) waiting to be written by me: Amish Buffalo Wind generators