poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 10321–10340 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

Ranger on Gunsong by MacFrantic 21 Feb 2006, 6:38 AM
I've just had a reread of this and I have to admit that 'Alive and frequently mortal' has to be one of my favourite lines on this site. Class.
MacFrantic on lost souls by aamir_trichy 21 Feb 2006, 6:30 AM
Ugh, this caves in fast. *4*
MacFrantic on Sunday i will dream again by Caducus 21 Feb 2006, 6:28 AM
This is very satisfying, but a few of the adj's seem forced. A I wish I could give you a 9.5, because with a couple tweaks this is an 11 for me. *9*
MacFrantic replying on First Unborn Sun by Been Here Before 21 Feb 2006, 6:24 AM
Agreed with Ranger, and there are still a few things that irk me. Maybe get rid of the "it" in "I cannot watch..." Great flow though. *7*
Ranger on Sunday i will dream again by Caducus 21 Feb 2006, 6:18 AM
Damn you Caducus, damn you to poetic injustice, you have presented me with a set of stanzas which individually are worth their weight in gold. But they don't click with each other, the joints are missing here. Each stanza has at least one absolute gem of a line in, it seems to me that you have stanzas from seven different poems put together here though. If I've missed something very important (and it's highly plausible that I have, my brain is somewhat fried right now) tell me and I will alter my reading accordingly. PS since I disappeared from the ranker you started writing some unbelievable stuff; I feel like I missed out!
ALChemy replying on Everything That You've Ever Wanted by drnick 21 Feb 2006, 6:14 AM
Not if you wished it to be exciting. If all our wishes were granted we'd have to exist in seperate universes or we would eventually be slaves to the wishes of the most creative, ingenious and opportunistic among us.
Ranger replying on lost souls by aamir_trichy 21 Feb 2006, 6:13 AM
And they are by no means bad lines. I'm just suggesting what I would do if they were *my* lines; if you disagree then that is absolutely fine - I'm not going to tell someone what they have to do in their poems. Write for yourself first and foremost, but when you want to write for other people, listen to what they say.
I like the beginning lines. Change line 10. Asking for a language that has no lies is like asking for a hammer that hits no thumbs. It's how language is used that dictates whether there are lies present. I don't quite get the last line. Are you saying that your invented world is boring or the world you're in now?
aamir_trichy replying on lost souls by aamir_trichy 21 Feb 2006, 5:24 AM
my first ever lines on sceen!!!!
Scarlett replying on Empty Chronicles by Scarlett 21 Feb 2006, 4:50 AM
Why, thank you, Ranger!
Ranger on First Unborn Sun by Been Here Before 21 Feb 2006, 2:57 AM
This gave me shivers. Edit the typos in stanza 1 ('creeping' and 'blind') so I can give you a vote.
Ranger on lost souls by aamir_trichy 21 Feb 2006, 2:52 AM
Personally I would leave out 'Cause' (line 2) as it interrupts the flow, and I wouldn't bother with 'Tis' either. It's too archaic for the feel of this poem.
Ranger on Empty Chronicles by Scarlett 21 Feb 2006, 2:43 AM
Mmm, yes now this I like. 'Wisest not to bud', 'Inspiration melts', '"Bloom me mulberry"', so beautiful. Absolutely lovely.
Ranger on Home is Where the Hate Is by raven_the_poet 21 Feb 2006, 2:30 AM
Okay, not bad. As a general point, I'm not sure prose poems have choruses - they're supposed to be more storylike, at least in my interpretation of the term. But that isn't important right now. In the first stanza I would use 'who' instead of 'that' (as you're referring to a person rather than an object) - also the last line in stanza 1 is a bit short; it stops abruptly in comparison to the other lines. I like the way stanza 2 goes quickly - I get the impression of someone whispering it over the shoulder, get rid of 'cause' though (and split that line into 2 lines) to keep the rhythm flowing. The last stanza is good, a little untidy at the moment, but with a bit of trimming it'll be fine.
Ranger replying on Conflict Resolution by Dovina 21 Feb 2006, 2:13 AM
We weren't arguing, just searching for a peaceful conflict resolution. As for the edit, I like it more now - hence the improved score - but the only problem I have is that by saying 'the anvil' you imply that it's a recurring theme, or at least something you've already introduced us to before (I've been guilty of doing this on countless occasions). Is the anvil her heart, her confidence? Or are the words ricocheting back to you, deflected off her stubbornness? It seems to me that stanza 2 could be read either way, which isn't a bad thing but if you want the ambiguity then ironically enough it seems as though you need to express your desire for such ambiguity. I do like this one though. Useful, Ma'am?
And if we obtain everything we wanted, ~ yes, how boring that would be... the expression, "money doesn't buy everything" derives from that, but even more so - if every wish comes true, then what is tomorrow for. I enjoyed the ponderings this poem brought to mind.
There is an internal and line ending rhyme that keeps the river flow of this going. Nice indeed. The only line that I stumbled on was this: “With breeze they softly are stirred” With “freeze” right at the end going into “with breeze” something didn’t catch. Over all though, enjoyed.
Scarlett on Beauty, sleeping (revised) by Ranger 20 Feb 2006, 6:15 PM
A touch of fairytale dreams and real life entanglements, this is well rounded, including the sense of humor. Enjoyed!
god'swife on Sonnet for Snow by ecargo 20 Feb 2006, 5:33 PM
Lovely. One small suggestion; change 'the eye turns..' to 'and the eye...' You have 'turns' in the first line and turns with truer is a bit stiff.
Dovina on The chestnut by richa 20 Feb 2006, 5:22 PM
It seems like a sad condition - alone under a chestnut tree, drinking, watching an unobtainable girl. I would wager that most people are happier when they drive to work.