ALChemy
on You. by Sway
26 Jan 2006, 6:24 AM
Good but lose the rhymes or find better ones.
Just the image of seeing a birch in winter that appears to be filled with pretty red leaves and then realizing they're a large flock of cardinals as they fly off.
It's very difficult to take this seriously.
The first parts well down, but then it kind of becomes nonsense. What happened to the sill in the first line?
This is nutty. Nothing makes sense.
What have you been smokin'?
And can we know what they are?
amanda_dcosta: there are birches with red leaves, apparently--I was seeing it through my own geographical filter (where birches with red leaves would be unusual). Does it matter that it's precise, correct? That's for you to decide. For me? Depends on context and purpose--I don't mind poetic license for point or purpose or even effect, but if I read something as literal (I do, too often), then I like it to be pretty accurate. OTOH, I've "leafed" trees in birds, so who am I to judge?
What things appear to be and what they are can be different.
I'm glad you got it, after all, your poem inspired it.
No, I think I'm relieved. All those birds flew right over my poor pedantic, literal head and I thought I didn't see them.
Uh... well there's certainly plenty of scenery. I've read this 3 times and i still don't know what it's talking about.
Nope that's pretty much it. Just thought that was a neat image worth haikuing. Just the image of seeing a birch in winter that appears to be filled with pretty red leaves and then realizing they're a large flock of cardinals as they fly off. The image seems to lend itself to some symbolism the reader can make their own. I hope your not disappointed.
Metaphors sweetie, metaphors. As sweet as...
Thin like....etc.
Also 'laid' rhymes enough with 'plain' that you don't need to use the word 'lain'. When i read that line I laughed, and that doesn't seem to be your intention.
Also what does rhythm have to do with feeling emotions?
If this poem is about something you have experienced then write about what happened to make you feel this way about him.
I not a fan of poems that reflect a thought directly. I wan't a story. Where's the story?
Looks are deceiving.