ALChemy
replying on Sunlighting by ALChemy
6 Jan 2006, 7:32 AM
To do it your way would pull the fragmented sentence farther away from the sentence it's complementing.
"To be or not to be: that is the question." Thank God Willy didn't listen to you. I may need a comma though, I'll give you that, or a colon after "sarong" and "caress". Punctuation isn't my strong point. What kind of sentence is "Eternal pasteless now." by the way? Oh I see it's different when you do it.
In short, of course it's not a complete sentence. So.
Excuse me?
"Soft, cushy, tushy never missed by eyes.
Surrounded by thick, ham like thighs."
Is this a description of your personality? Because if it is, I beg pardon, you're obviously very interesting...
I assure you I caught your *point* in the poem, since it was glaringly obvious. But my previous statements still hold; you leave no room for thought, and instead you bombard the reader with a one-sided statement. It's like being force-fed. You don't really enjoy the food.
The word "that" makes it not a sentence.
Thanks D.
It's certainly more efficient but by stretching the sentence I think it causes the reader to linger on the images a little longer. But I'm still considering it.
Some nice thoughts here. It's a prose poem at best. Not free verse. As a short story it might be better.
I see no reason for not introducing a Short Story category, under 500 words.
A lovely, fanciful expression. I think "emerald dress that stretches to the horizonâs hem" would sound better and become grammatical as "emerald dress stretches to horizonâs hem"
Kindly do not assume what I do or don't assume.
If you read the aboveposted text years ago, forgot it, and then rewrote it, that's still plagiarism, albeit obviously accidental plagiarism. There are myriad cases of similar things happening.
If you've somehow independently written this without ANY prior experience with the text, I'm sorry I said you were a plagiarist. For what that's worth. In either event, it would obviously still be a good idea, if not your responsibility, to rewrite or withdraw your version.
Yes, the fact that you've based your poem on a wordplay on a not-exactly-familiar phrase, "eternal pastless now", made me think you were thinking of some original phrase or text you knew. I cannot see how you'd think "eternal pasteless now" was clever or worthwhile otherwise.
Again, I'm sorry about this whole thing. I didn't wake up this beautiful snowy Alaska morning thinking I was going to be mean to you. I'd like to start being nice to you now, so maybe it's best we let this whole thing go for today.
I think you have a good idea for what a prose poem should be. I think this one just needs more ambience.
I read âThe Correctionsâ by Jonathan Franzen a couple of years ago, the same author who wrote âMy Fatherâs Brainâ which you cited and in which he quotes David Shenk. âThe Correctionsâ deals with old age issues and may contain some of the same language David Shenk used. Iâd have to go through it again to know. What I do know is that phrases stick in my head and tend to come out in my writing even if I read them years before. Of course, you always assume the worst and call it the most logical.
That's fine. Whatever.
I did not know about that book. Nothing is copied.
I'm not from the south so I couldn't relate. But just through your description it's as if I was there and I knew all about it.
I don't want to argue about it; it's just that I find that impossible to believe. Look, I can practically write your poem from article quotes:
"The Forgetting"
"you stoop to smell a rose,"
"the same rose" "that you've been stooping to smell" "all morning" ...
"delicious in oblivion"
"eternal, pastless Now"
No, "he tasted everything new" isn't in the article. But it's not grammatical either. Take credit for it if you like.
Look, I'm really, really, REALLY not looking to give you a hard time. The only reason I know about the article is that I was looking up a poem I remembered with the narrator stooping to smell a rose (Edmund Waller, maybe?) to congratulate you on referencing it. Let's let the readers decide for themselves. I'd personally like to believe you read New Yorker, The Guardian, or obscure neurology texts.
Lmao, I'm fine with the way I look. I get the men I want and then some.. So ZODIAC me being not so good looking to you isn't my problem; it's yours.
I did not know about that book. Nothing is copied.
OK done deal. Dawn stays.
Most people go to these far off places in search of adventure. You just seem to get Forest Gumped into them. Lucky for you, you're a writer.
ZODIAC: ***PLAGIARY ALERT***
Dovina: Not so. I changed pastless to pasteless. It's an allusion.
ZODIAC: The title, central image, and 95% of the words aren't yours.
DOVINA: I'm an illusion.
ZODIAC: I don't have time for this. You've been warned. Again.
Sometimes man, you just plain old scare me.