poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 1981–2000 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

Skamper replying on AKA Poets by Skamper 19 Nov 2007, 6:46 PM
I read an interview with him - don't know how long ago he gave it but he seemed to be more about writing to be understood (with flair of course) by his readers. He took a scathing look at those who write obscurely...but then admitted to doing that himself at one point. I like his style - but I could get bored easily with it. Do you call yourself poet?
Skamper replying on AKA Poets by Skamper 19 Nov 2007, 6:42 PM
yep...the first two lines just about sum it all up...love it!
malpaso on What bianca saw!!! by titan69 19 Nov 2007, 6:33 AM
the most ignorant, piss-poor limerick I ever heard but funny, though and proves that with a little embedded irony and slant rhyme you can have a good time and actually...polish a turd!
MacFrantic replying on A Vernal Tale by MacFrantic 18 Nov 2007, 3:13 PM
Thanks, that was very helpful.
INTRANSIT on Liar by Roisin 18 Nov 2007, 7:17 AM
I would make the first stanza four lines and give -bitch- its own. I think you can lose -glinting and move suffocated by sin up. I'd also like ahint as to who is catching the hot lead. hope that helps.
INTRANSIT on A Vernal Tale by MacFrantic 18 Nov 2007, 7:11 AM
Suggestions. Lines 4,8,10 no comma L-11 split? or spilt? L-16 no comma / changet to -though L-18 IN soil Last stanza go 4 lines Penultimate- one comma after year Last line-- the? instead of her?
hobojo replying on Fading Love by hobojo 18 Nov 2007, 2:01 AM
Thanks
some deleted user on AKA Poets by Skamper 17 Nov 2007, 6:32 AM
Excellent, excellent, excellent.
some deleted user on The Taking by Skamper 17 Nov 2007, 6:28 AM
so much said with so little words.
INTRANSIT on Tingling by INTRANSIT 16 Nov 2007, 8:21 AM
Dropped the -crimson. Reformed into stanzas. I'm wondering if -melon- is too vague.
INTRANSIT replying on AKA Poets by Skamper 16 Nov 2007, 7:59 AM
my original reference was to the introduction written by Collins in the 2006 edition of "The best American poetry" He's somewhat scathing while he talks about how many small publishers there are and how much "bad" poetry could get out. I kind of agree, but only as far as my own personality will allow. He kind of goes back on himself in the end of the intro, though. Ha! so much going on, we poets don't know which way to turn sometimes.
INTRANSIT replying on AKA Poets by Skamper 16 Nov 2007, 7:52 AM
excerpt from "The trouble with poetry" By Mr. Collins the trouble with poetry is that it encourages the writing of more poetry, more guppies crowding the fish tank, more baby rabbits hopping out of their mothers into the dewey grass.
INTRANSIT on The Taking by Skamper 16 Nov 2007, 7:34 AM
For some reason, I'd like lines one and two inverted. Leave the big gap but lose the -then- Love it!
INTRANSIT replying on It's about truckin' by INTRANSIT 16 Nov 2007, 7:29 AM
Well Skamper, after doing this for some 11 years now, appealing is not a word (I) would use. Trucking for me was more of a "seemed like a good idea at the time" thing. Sorry to dissapoint. When I first started it was a neat new challenge. Now it's more like wrote. Emphasis on "like". It does have its moments and I'll bump up an older poem that I've been wanting to revisit.
no but I wish there had been
Skamper replying on AKA Poets by Skamper 16 Nov 2007, 2:18 AM
I noticed when I googled Billy Collins that he's written a book on the trouble with poetry...I have to get my hands on that. I am gonna look to see if I can find the poem you're referring to, exciting to find another like mind. :)
Skamper replying on AKA Poets by Skamper 16 Nov 2007, 2:14 AM
BTW I think your exactly the person who should be writing poetry, I think Billy would back me all the way on that!
Skamper replying on AKA Poets by Skamper 16 Nov 2007, 2:13 AM
I googled Billy Collins and read some of his stuff. At first I thought he was dull, but after a few reads I see the appeal. Only recently did I discover that the title 'Poet Laureate' isn't just a self proclamation. Thanks for adding to my education once again. :)
Skamper on It's about truckin' by INTRANSIT 16 Nov 2007, 2:07 AM
Since I've been travelling and no doubt annoying the hell out of truckies (going 80k's when the limits 110) I've developed a need to know why this kind of life is so appealing. I say life, instead of work beacuse I feel in another time I think I could have lived this way. Could you write about this aspect, or have you done so? I like this poem's descriptive, insightful picture of what the life entails. But, would love to read about why.
Skamper on INTELLIGENCIA by INTRANSIT 16 Nov 2007, 1:41 AM
there's always a line that needs something - I see what you mean about line 8, it's a little clumsy. Yet, the line works so well with a pause after own.