-=Dark_Angel=-, P.I.4 Apr 2005

Wrong. The Liar-Confuser has to answer the question you ask. And he has to lie. If he randomly changes "the shortest description of his reason" as the letters unfold, then he is not answering your question. Your questions are continually referring to THE description you asked him to think about in the first question, and any deviation from that on his part is an instance of not answering the question.

You may say "Oh he's a confuser he doesn't have to answer your question" but that's silly, because then he could just say "wibble", or keep silent the whole time, which is OBVIOUSLY not what we mean by a Liar-Confuser.