zodiac22 Apr 2005

Don't assume. All those comments except the first have at least something to do with the poem, and most of them are helpful suggestions (i.e., the comment on Psydeways Tears's poems).

By contrast, the comments you've posted on OTHER PEOPLE'S POEMS BESIDES YOUR OWN are:

"Sorry I have never rated any of your poems I am just at work when I am on the net. Nice feel although not a dastic subject, plus how can I say anything bad to someone who has offered nothing but support. Keep up the good work and get in contact with me about publishing books as this is a dream of mine.
Love the style"

"Very nice mouthfull, love the style, great talent and wonderfullllll subject. "

"No real movement for me but it does represent what you can do with words."

And

"Feels like something I would of wrote. I trulty feel the meaning, if only these other "critiques" could see that."

Can you honestly say that any of these poems gives a useful suggestion or does anything else except

a) give vague fluffy praise,
b) trash the poem in a vague, rather fluffy way, or
c) trash "critiques"?