Ranger
replying on The Demonbaker's Death by PsydewaysTears
3 Jul 2007, 2:39 AM
What am I supposed to say if people keep stealing my comments in advance?
It works better now. 'Sways to wind and rain' is exactly what I was talking about. Perhaps a couple more sibilants in some places to keep a constant hissing of grass? Maybe that would be a little over the top, but it might be worthwhile playing around with the sound.
This is very good in many places, but when you force the rhymes it loses some of its intensity. If you want to rhyme (I love rhymed poetry) then try using a rhyming dictionary - there are plenty of good ones online - for greater variety. Throwing in some unobvious rhymes here and there usually works well, but the most important thing is to remember that rhyme is a rhythmic device, and should be subtle rather than forced.
I hope this isn't from your own experience.
Typos line 3, stanzas 13 and 14. I think if you shortened this, compacted the abuses you describe, it would have more impact. Still a decent write though.
The images here are very good Dovina. You have taken something simple and ordinary, something most of us take for granted, and raised it to the extraordinary--great insight and a great write.
i do like the rhythm that (it appears) you have tweaked. whatever, it works well with the theme.
i hear the wind on this prairie, the soft subtle moaning through the blades as they rustle, bending and sweeping their neighbors.
i also like the slow outward zoom, if you will, going from micro to macro, although if this was intentional, there are a few places where it breaks the progression: s3 & s5 zoom much further out.
something about the last stanza is uncomfortable. i guess putting yourself into the piece brings the image of the expanse of the prairie to bear, but doesn't sit well with me. much in the same way that some tlevision commercials will lead in with some awe-inspiring imagery, only to ruin the effect by presenting their product. but that is personal preference...
still, a great piece. thanks.
Actually, that's quite a serious allegation in Poemrankerland. I'd like to know why you said that.
Er... I didn't. How could I? I don't think the site even allows you to do that, does it?
ugh.
horrid topic, well portrayed. i think that the single line "hear our silence" is sufficient to convey the "shame on spectators" message.
especially haunting is the last verse...
wonderful.
Interesting - I can't see where to punctuate this without interrupting the flow of the thing. Suggestions?
Isn't that the way of the poet - mixing of both memory and imagination. Even a memory is never true to the event. This is good stuff, I enjoyed it.
notice how your first stanzas are shorter lines? That works really well - stick to that. I love the fantasy/goth feel of this...
didnt like it at first but after reading it a few times i think it grows on you.
makes you think. interesting.
I agree with what ranger will say: Too much prose, too little rhythm. The same story will sound better with iambs and such. It's a good story.