poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 5721–5740 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

Ranger on Prayer by amanda_dcosta 21 Sep 2006, 12:31 AM
Hey Amanda, sorry I've not yet replied to your email. I will though, bear with me! This seems very much like a short psalm; lyrical and dramatic. I'd split line 2 into two (finish on 'night'), and finish line 3 on something other than '-ing' (give it a word with a strong ending). Still nice, needs music methinks :-)
flock replying on The Surfer's Prayer by flock 21 Sep 2006, 12:12 AM
everything.
half.italian on I Have, Because I Am by flock 20 Sep 2006, 8:55 PM
I kind of liked the first few stanzas, but it just got worse as it went on, and then worse again until the final cliche ruined it entirely.
pete replying on Flea poem by Sing4Jesus! 20 Sep 2006, 7:50 PM
damn freud with his ego-system small minds inhabit large legends
colbaby on Fun At The Gynaecologists by Edna Sweetlove 20 Sep 2006, 6:02 PM
Women have all the fun. I wish I was one. I'm going to the dentist. 9/10.
Edna Sweetlove replying on Flea poem by Sing4Jesus! 20 Sep 2006, 5:10 PM
You sound like a moronic nerd. Why not rate it instead of writing illiterate turd-shite?
Edna Sweetlove on love is true by -=??lilaznjen??=- 20 Sep 2006, 5:08 PM
You appear to be ill.
Edna Sweetlove on life by -=??lilaznjen??=- 20 Sep 2006, 5:07 PM
10/10 for tragic garbage.
Edna Sweetlove on Jesus by Sing4Jesus! 20 Sep 2006, 5:05 PM
Hilarious. You are clearly demented.
Edna Sweetlove on The Surfer's Prayer by flock 20 Sep 2006, 5:04 PM
What the "Lord" has to do with it, I really D.K.
Edna Sweetlove on Ellipses by MacFrantic 20 Sep 2006, 5:03 PM
You have shown promise here. But this is total ratshit.
Edna Sweetlove on Songs of the hedge bird by ALChemy 20 Sep 2006, 5:02 PM
Slop.
Edna Sweetlove on Quatrain by ALChemy 20 Sep 2006, 5:01 PM
No.
Edna Sweetlove on Constipation by colbaby 20 Sep 2006, 4:59 PM
This is charming indeed. I am tempted to give 10/10 but 9 will have to do, mainly because you omitted any mentioned of the joy of a self-administered soapy enema.
Edna Sweetlove on Constipation by colbaby 20 Sep 2006, 4:59 PM
This is charming indeed. I am tempted to give 10/10 but 9 will have to do, mainly because you omitted any mentioned of the joy of a self-administered soapy enema.
colbaby replying on Constipation by colbaby 20 Sep 2006, 4:52 PM
I'm in Sydney and I feel like a pint.
dvincent on In the hollow (rough) by ecargo 20 Sep 2006, 4:30 PM
Ecargo This is nice, dreamy, lyrical poem with some intersting memories and vivid descriptions. And you've gone for the fine detail, the wonderful small things (... brown, bare legs...crosshatched with careless priker scrapes..." and (...tapping in and out, double-time running hollows..) We don't often think about these, but they're what makes the poem a very intimate and honest expereince. You also have some choices that are a little too easy (e.g. we think of them right away) "...hard hands and jagged voices..." "pussy-willow spring..." "sang their soft night songs..." These have no suprise or punch. Hold out for the fresh surprises, not the "usual". Good poem!
dvincent on Farewell, Kind Lover by Dovina 20 Sep 2006, 3:27 PM
I just had to comment on one phrase, "...sprouts feeling the sky for {a} twist of updraft" Very clean and unique. Sorry for inserting the "a". That's the only change I would have made. Good work.
dvincent on Once they were gliders. by half.italian 20 Sep 2006, 3:19 PM
Half.italian Your imagery and lyrical cadences are great -- "Hack along making tin out of silience." "gutter up and sigh in turn." That's good, vivid and musical language. One thing I just realized that I think would help this. You should have named it simply "Cars" and in the second line where you say the word "cars" maybe changed that to "coupes" (the choked up coupes)or "sedans" or "wagons" or... not sure. Anyway, very nice poem.
Ranger on In the hollow (rough) by ecargo 20 Sep 2006, 12:26 PM
Love the content, don't love the mixed stresses at the line ends (you can tell I've been reading about this stuff, can't you? Credit/blame must go to Stephen Fry) - you could get away with all feminine endings in the first stanza (representing the little girl) but in stanza 2 where you talk about 'hard hands' and 'jagged voices' I'd make the line end sharply. Can't complain about the imagery though, and the language, as always, is beautiful :-)