poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 5761–5780 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

Ranger on Last flight of a goose by Bobjim 19 Sep 2006, 12:49 PM
Agreed with richa, order it 3,4,1,2. This is legendary :-)
Ranger replying on The Secret by ecargo 19 Sep 2006, 12:42 PM
You should enter it (assuming the entry fee isn't something like a thousand dollars) - particularly if you can include Selkie in your collection. Nothing ventured, nothing gained indeed - and you might well surprise yourself :-) Do you write fiction other than poetry?
Ranger replying on The Secret by ecargo 19 Sep 2006, 12:39 PM
Ah, I thought you were being specific - a secret miscarriage. I was quite concerned by the last line (on this reading) though - I mean, how many dead babies had been buried?! And were they all yours or were there - God forbid - prawnes inamongst the corpses too? Question: was there a prawn unit in the war, or indeed, in any war?
Ranger replying on The Secret by ecargo 19 Sep 2006, 12:34 PM
True, but you have to go abroad to get people to notice it...
Ranger on Jose Streets by SupremeDreamer 19 Sep 2006, 12:29 PM
Argh! The curse of the "'n" strikes again! I know, I know, I'm a Queen's English snob, I'll get over it one day... Anyway, I quite liked the story but struggled to get the beat to it. ecargo's better at this than me, but I do think it wants reworking, or maybe just reclassifying. Done as prose it would seem very akin to the monologue introduction to a character story (does need to be spoken though). Decent enough, let me know if you do any edits of this; I'd be interested to read :-)
half.italian replying on Week End Justification by half.italian 19 Sep 2006, 9:33 AM
If you see it and it works, Its there. My subconcious tends to do some amazing things when I'm not thinking. :)
ecargo on Constipation by colbaby 19 Sep 2006, 9:22 AM
Not bad, as shit poems go. ;-) And we are, after all, the Shittiest Poetry Site on the Web (more float per inch!) (TM). Of course, nothing can match the vigor and explosive power of the -=DA-=PI classic, _Child of My Buttocks_: http://www.poemranker.com/poem-details.jsp?id=20331.
ecargo replying on The Secret by ecargo 19 Sep 2006, 9:12 AM
Ya know, it's not. It's just an incredibly heavy-handed metaphor for carrying a secret, your own or, sometimes worse, someone else's, that weighs in your gut and plagues you. The miscarriage imagery was just a metaphor, but I think I may have overdone it--I knew what the obvious connotation would be. Thanks for the comment, Ranger! re: WWA (sounds like some WWII women's auxilary unit), I might, depending on what I can muster up. ;-) As I said, nothing ventured, nothing gained, and if nothing else, it'll let me do an inventory of my body of work, right? ("Body of work" makes it sound so imposing or impressive or something. It's not. ;-))
ecargo replying on The Secret by ecargo 19 Sep 2006, 9:08 AM
Aw, but you get to speak with that cool accent! ;-D
SupremeDreamer replying on Jose Streets by SupremeDreamer 19 Sep 2006, 9:01 AM
nypoet, let me clarify something for you: Toons is an actual night club in san jose, california, right on the corner of second and santa clara. I didn't make up the name, they did. Heh. Thanks for the comments & vote.
Ranger replying on Week End Justification by half.italian 19 Sep 2006, 8:11 AM
Dammit, I must have been slow-thinking recently. More so than usual, anyway. There's most certainly a pun in here - 'weakened justification', relating to the excesses of stanza 2 - and if there isn't, there should be. Upping the score for that, and also because every time I read this the last two lines get more and more fun.
Ranger on Head Exploding Mark 2 by pink_escape 19 Sep 2006, 8:06 AM
Genius title.
Ranger on Fare Price (Final Version) by Wakeboarder20 19 Sep 2006, 8:05 AM
If I remember rightly, I quite liked the original. Decent enough edit, although I can never quite be sure whether you're religious or not.
Ranger on Constipation by colbaby 19 Sep 2006, 8:01 AM
Oh, how I laughed. I thought it was only the British who were allowed this sort of humour.
Ranger on Pale Blue by MacFrantic 19 Sep 2006, 7:59 AM
Oh, I must have missed this when it was posted. Nice, stanzas 2 and 3 especially. Could do with working on the stresses a bit.
Ranger replying on Final Goregasm by creepshow 19 Sep 2006, 7:57 AM
Chips with that, please.
Ranger on Staring through you by creepshow 19 Sep 2006, 7:56 AM
Nasty poems work best with a solid structure for guidance. This, although undeniably nasty, could do with being structured. As it is, it reads like a stop-start collection of thoughts - which doesn't flow very well. By the way, do you really do all this?
Ranger on Sublime by nightowl 19 Sep 2006, 7:52 AM
Decent enough, could do with having the metre worked on though. I'd make the second line consistent with the internal rhymes of the other three. 'Companion/champion' is nice.
Ranger on The Secret by ecargo 19 Sep 2006, 7:50 AM
This is a miscarriage poem, right? You've got an odd timing in here - I can make most of it fit, but the first line throws it somewhat. With a slow reading it fits, but I found it still a little awkward. Are you entering the WWA?
Ranger replying on The Secret by ecargo 19 Sep 2006, 7:45 AM
Damn my British citizenship!