poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 64161–64180 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

I tire of pain and misery so I read pieces too fast. I missed the (he) and therefore missed the triangle. But a fascinating view!8
INTRANSIT on happy hour by Limness 24 Sep 2002, 5:14 AM
Well, so much for writing about the 9-5 crowd. Covered it better than I might've.9
Katie on Wedding Day... by loneshadow29 24 Sep 2002, 4:30 AM
I like the idea of this poem, it's one no one else here has tried, So it's something new for a change. and even if you don't like it..well it means something to him anyway, so unless you have something nice to say, or advice to make the poem any better, then don't say anything at all. I think it's a great poem shadow! =)
Katie on A Gift of Beauty... by loneshadow29 24 Sep 2002, 4:24 AM
*snif*snif, that's so pretty!! It's a 10 all the way
This is certainly a tangle beyond my limited comprehension. Somehow the pronouns evoke this confusion, but I agree that it could be a bit clearer. Nonetheless, I like this, a slice of (thankfully for me) someone else's.
Christof replying on The Hand of God by Christof 24 Sep 2002, 12:59 AM
I don't know but I'm glad to see that you like it my friend!
vulcan on Unveiled by aperfecttool77 24 Sep 2002, 12:32 AM
Don't you think that your poem recalls no special atmosphere in one's mind.It looks and sounds blank.you lack words as you've said in your poem.add something blanker at least at the end and i'll like your style.
vulcan replying on Unveiled by aperfecttool77 24 Sep 2002, 12:29 AM
a charming answer!
OneFingerAnswer replying on Unveiled by aperfecttool77 24 Sep 2002, 12:19 AM
Expression in this format is poetry though. A wall well painted is not art but there has been an artist who painted black squares on a black canvas and it recieved acclaim as a great piece of art. I found it to be bad but I couldn't deny that it was art.
god'swife replying on Unveiled by aperfecttool77 24 Sep 2002, 12:13 AM
It's not about power. Expression is not poetry. No more then a wall well painted is art.
OneFingerAnswer replying on Unveiled by aperfecttool77 24 Sep 2002, 12:12 AM
I see a style to it. He repeats a single line then puts a twist on it at the end. Once again, you're mistaking your dislike of something for it's lack. Just because you don't like the style he used doesn't mean it's not there.
god'swife replying on Unveiled by aperfecttool77 24 Sep 2002, 12:08 AM
But even when they "tell it like it is" as you put it, they make it uniquely interesting. They don't just say what happened in some unstylized manner.
OneFingerAnswer replying on Unveiled by aperfecttool77 24 Sep 2002, 12:06 AM
They can say it's not good art. You can say it's not a good poem. That is where your power ends.
god'swife replying on Unveiled by aperfecttool77 24 Sep 2002, 12:02 AM
I cannot deny it holds no poetry for me. Some people hate any number of "artists" therefore their creations are not art to those that don't like them. I can believe I am the greateast artist in the world but til I have an audience, I'm shit. I can say this is not a poem. This is not a poem.
I'll think about it. I won't be doing it tonight though. Thank you for advice that extends beyond "It's boring."
god'swife replying on Triangle of the Courtyard Square by OneFingerAnswer 23 Sep 2002, 11:54 PM
Yes, but I long for the He's, She's and Me's to be more seperate. Like a triangle. Each coming from his own direction. I think S2 is quite fine. If you can keep them seperate somehow. Bring them together at the end. Maybe write 3 stanzas were you address them and their needs individually. This is more of a pentagram then a triangle.
OneFingerAnswer replying on Unveiled by aperfecttool77 23 Sep 2002, 11:50 PM
Sometimes I want garlic sometimes I want beans. Some people can't stand beans and others hate garlic. It's all personal taste. You can say that the poem is to plain for you but you cannot deny it standing as a poem.
OneFingerAnswer replying on Unveiled by aperfecttool77 23 Sep 2002, 11:47 PM
Ahh... as writers I love many people. Most of them are lyricists. Most of my poetry actually starts in my head as a song and thus it is these people I look to for insperation. Sometimes they use colorful and fancy language. Sometimes they just tell it how it is.
god'swife replying on Unveiled by aperfecttool77 23 Sep 2002, 11:45 PM
There's nothing wrong with it. Beans are beans. Some people add garlic, a bit of rosemary, a little olive oil perhaps. They make a poem of it. Otherwise it plain beans. Which would you rather?
god'swife replying on Unveiled by aperfecttool77 23 Sep 2002, 11:42 PM
They have everything to do with the quality of this poem. I mean love as in love as writers.