poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 65561–65580 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

[mojo] on Putney at Low Tide by Christof 10 Sep 2002, 2:39 PM
"Beshitten". Someone contact the Oxford new words dept:) Outstanding imagery. 9.
[mojo] on Thank You Mom by savannah 10 Sep 2002, 2:33 PM
Thanks, but no thanks. Borderline nauseating.1. (Hey I'm sure your "mom" will give it 10.)
Beautiful but ever so slightly uninteresting. Can't fault the word choice or structure, can't award anything less than a 9 in fairness, but don't feel "rewarded" for having read it...if you know what i mean?
[mojo] on My cousin's baby sitter. by Bachus 10 Sep 2002, 2:28 PM
Charming.
beakism on Leaf on the wind by troll454 10 Sep 2002, 2:03 PM
Besides the obvious, rather unremarkable final two lines, I don't see that this poem has anything to recommend it. Presumably the high votes are due to its emotional subject, but banal writing cannot stand up on its subject matter.
nentwined on Russian Roulette by <~> 10 Sep 2002, 2:03 PM
hmm. this was too proselike for my taste, and the intro ditty really didn't do it for me. the "form" is somewhat interesting, but could still _flow_ better.
some deleted user on Inner Peace by god 10 Sep 2002, 1:57 PM
"God?" and wasn't this already submitted by someone else?
nentwined on Leaf on the wind by troll454 10 Sep 2002, 1:55 PM
I can't say this moved me.
[mojo] on Words by PawnedTidal 10 Sep 2002, 12:49 PM
A little obvious.5.
[mojo] on Oaxaca city fragment by poetandknowit 10 Sep 2002, 12:43 PM
Hard to read, guess that makes it well written? Hard to give a particularly good score to something so unpleasant.7. Hey, enough of the poetry advice, you need some travel guidance...next time go to Taxco, it's pretty. Come to think of it Mexico City seems better than the place you describe :). Hell, make that 8, it makes me feel good about living in the UK.
<~> replying on Lavendar Gate by <~> 10 Sep 2002, 12:43 PM
yes. it was run by anglophiles who subsequently moved to england. it was very much a literary romantic's dream-come-true
god'swife replying on Lavendar Gate by <~> 10 Sep 2002, 12:37 PM
oh! So the place itself was a little overdone for it's setting. You establish the sense of quiet late evening very well. I picture you in flannels.
<~> replying on Lavendar Gate by <~> 10 Sep 2002, 12:14 PM
yeah. but this is and oldie, dredged up. it's a decade old. the suite was done up in william morris green wallpaper, and it was a garret, so it fits. 'lavendar gate' was a b&b in marblehead, mass. it's now defunct. it was in an old parson's house, right next to the church...
god'swife on Lavendar Gate by <~> 10 Sep 2002, 12:01 PM
Lovely. "Green-swathed" & "attic keep" seem slightly pretentious in this setting. Stanza 1 has a simpler voice.
Tarquin De La Bog on Winter by morffrom 10 Sep 2002, 11:57 AM
This is both sweet and lovely, but also inaccurate. Is a frozen butterfly (note the 'r' in the correct spelling) really a tear in heaven? I very much doubt it, but for your beautiful imagery you score 8 regardless. However, the haiku is rather whimsical and vague. What exactly are you trying to convey? I have no idea, and I suspect that you don't either.
Tarquin De La Bog on My cousin's baby sitter. by Bachus 10 Sep 2002, 11:50 AM
Clever. 8. The second stanza is the weakest, but the final two are excellent. However young man, you're currently breaking the law by having underage sex, and have been reported to the relevant authorities already. Look forward to a lifetime of desperately shielding your arse from fellow inmates.
Tarquin De La Bog on Ever Felt by nightii 10 Sep 2002, 11:31 AM
I like this. 8. The drug references are risque (have you ever noticed that people shy away from commenting on poems alluding to drugs?) but nicely done, and the final section ends the poem succinctly. The short lines add atmosphere to the piece. I'm impressed.
<~> on My cousin's baby sitter. by Bachus 10 Sep 2002, 11:24 AM
and again
<~> on My cousin's baby sitter. by Bachus 10 Sep 2002, 11:23 AM
sorry h. it's tew good to be bad. but here's a cupla zero for you, nonetheless.
bornagainpoet on Winter by morffrom 10 Sep 2002, 10:15 AM
LOvely