poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 65641–65660 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

poetandknowit on untitled#3 by darby pyn 9 Sep 2002, 11:48 PM
I do not like this, so listen to GW. It is so well done (as in over cooked) that I can almost hear you trying to be clever. I want the words to come effortless; these seem forced and contrived. And add an apostrophe to your.
god'swife on untitled#3 by darby pyn 9 Sep 2002, 11:42 PM
Yes is my favorite word this evening. So yes. In my opinion this really starts working at "With one extended..." The first 4 and a half lines are some what overdone, dispite that, I like it.
<~> replying on Russian Roulette by <~> 9 Sep 2002, 11:39 PM
you always repell me p&k, but isn't that your self-proclaimed M.O.? 'just the blood' is the dual thing again, (the mess, the familial ties), and also because, dammit, it need the word 'just' to justify the structure--1st and last lines ea stanza are their own entities as well, and without 'just' it don't werk that way. yes, the hole is exaggerated in size. you got me. the act is big, so the hole has mirrored it. and in the kitchen, bastion of domesticity...
poetandknowit replying on Russian Roulette by <~> 9 Sep 2002, 11:31 PM
Not to be REPELLANT, but what kind of gun was this - could see kitchen through hole, but I guess the RR is referring to other things and not the actual act of the game, which is played with a revoler and most likely wouldn't make that kind of hole...well. I kind of like the idea of someone playing RR knowing the whole time they are going to play to lose. I don't know, you are describing an act from you view of a story from someone else and I kind of want to know the five knocks that pushed him to it. But that is another poem I guess. I also think the "mess" gives a clear image and "just the blood" goes overboard, but I suppose you are shooting for the double purpose, I am just not sure I like it.
god'swife on Russian Roulette by <~> 9 Sep 2002, 11:27 PM
Bravo sister. Keep sharpening your pencils. Solid 10s.
<~> replying on Russian Roulette by <~> 9 Sep 2002, 11:22 PM
i think that brings it around nicely.
god'swife on Russian Roulette by <~> 9 Sep 2002, 11:18 PM
Yes absolutely yes! Try making the 1st stanza, which will now be the 2nd, present tense. Does that sound better to you?
<~> replying on Russian Roulette by <~> 9 Sep 2002, 11:08 PM
i am thinking about making the '5 out of 6' stanza the 1st. any opinions as to how that would read?
<~> replying on Russian Roulette by <~> 9 Sep 2002, 11:06 PM
gracias, amiga. yes, her very own r&r. no helmet, and she often 'forgets' her night glasses, and rides in shades after dark... i'm sure there's a few more chambers, but i've only known her a year now. she is amazing, steel and mayfly...
god'swife on Russian Roulette by <~> 9 Sep 2002, 11:02 PM
4, 5, & 6 definitely. "The recoil sent you..." So good I closed my eyes. Yes. I also like the way she rides her moto without her helmet. Some R&R of her own. Whether you meant that way or not.
god'swife on Oaxaca city fragment by poetandknowit 9 Sep 2002, 10:51 PM
There is a strong contrast to your other poems. I like that effect. Although they too venture into the unseemly realities, this one is particulary dark. 40 words 13 of them harsh. I want to know more. Look to the left, look to the right. Walk down the street, enter. Plus you used my favorite word.
poetandknowit on A Well Worth Wait by savannah 9 Sep 2002, 10:48 PM
Hey you and BARBIE have the same exact ending. And even have ?????????? all over the place. Oh well, can never say it enough: ???????I LOVE YOU TOO?????
poetandknowit on I Love You!! by Babieflirt 9 Sep 2002, 10:47 PM
?????????I LOVE YOU TOO??????
poetandknowit replying on Russian Roulette by <~> 9 Sep 2002, 10:44 PM
Although irritable, edgy and, of course, opinionated by nature I am simply repellent so people will read my work. When I post something people read it 1) because it is good and 2) because I piss them off and they want to hate my work but cannot because it is too damn good.
<~> replying on Russian Roulette by <~> 9 Sep 2002, 10:39 PM
4 is tighter now, p&k. maybe i'll squeeze it some more tomorrow.
<~> on Waking Up by PawnedTidal 9 Sep 2002, 10:14 PM
this one's growing on me...
poetandknowit on Lonely Night by faded 9 Sep 2002, 10:08 PM
I just hear the flipping Brian or Bryan Adams song in my head, "Baby, I just can't stand another lonely night, so come over and save me...." and on and on. Plus, this poem is full of tender hearted cliches.
Frass replying on Russian Roulette by <~> 9 Sep 2002, 10:07 PM
Ya know, PAKI, as repellent as you are, quality analysis such as this makes me like you, just a little. Keep it up and always focus on the golden triangle (1.61803, ya know.....Do ya?).
<~> replying on Russian Roulette by <~> 9 Sep 2002, 10:07 PM
yes, laugh and crack are intentional repetitions. the second is an empathetic keening; does is make more sense as such, or still weak? you mean the comma by 'undone'? i think it has 2 meanings with the comma in and only one without it...yes. the 4th will be tightened, but this is less than 2 hours old now, so... thanks
poetandknowit on Russian Roulette by <~> 9 Sep 2002, 10:01 PM
You just changed the style of this. Last time it came up, I set it aside because of the style, so wise choice in the change. You used laugh in some form 5 times and crack 3 times - is it intended repetition? Third stanza is excellent, but I have trouble with the second and the poem seems to drag along at times to the end. Seems you mixed some moving and downright fine images, with "just getting it all out on paper." Take the comma from behind "left." I think it has more power without any pause and it creates a nice image. Just a thought. I don't know, I like the poem overall, (it is not a triangle) but it could use some tightening, especially in the 4th stanza.