poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 8001–8020 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

Dovina replying on A Bronze Mule by Dovina 19 Apr 2006, 5:19 PM
While that is not what I was thinking, I will allow you that interpretation. It's a far sight better than Hitler's rendering of the New Testament and Stephen Robins' take on WWII.
ALChemy replying on A Bronze Mule by Dovina 19 Apr 2006, 5:13 PM
I guess this could be the artist/theologist mule you're talking about. If so, I like the bronze idea.
Dovina on grim task by lmp 19 Apr 2006, 5:10 PM
Verses 1 and 2 are good. Verse 3 is awkward. The repeated line, "he collects himself and his meager pay" seems bland for a "grim task."
Dovina replying on A Bronze Mule by Dovina 19 Apr 2006, 5:04 PM
lol. I have had 0. Explain that!
Dovina on The Waiting Room by Sunny 19 Apr 2006, 5:03 PM
I like the ambiguous ending. I think such an ending deserves tightness throughout. That would make it stronger, I think. "These depictions are levitating inside my peripherals" could "depictions levitate." "I recognize this room as a waiting room." -> "a waiting room." concrete certainties are the same as just "certainties." etc.
ALChemy replying on A Bronze Mule by Dovina 19 Apr 2006, 4:57 PM
I always thought the rule of 3 was that you can tell how many women a man has had by dividing the amount he gives by 3 and you can tell how many men a woman has had by multiplying the amount she gives by 3.
Dovina replying on A Bronze Mule by Dovina 19 Apr 2006, 4:53 PM
Then you have a feeling for what it means. Go for explaining it please. And do not worry that I will impose the pompspouter rule again.
ALChemy on A Bronze Mule by Dovina 19 Apr 2006, 4:50 PM
I love this. I have no idea what it means but I love it.
lmp on Murder Phoenix Born (meta-villanelle) by Ranger 19 Apr 2006, 4:12 PM
this is so great.... question about line 8: "The flash of early column light"... would this be a little clearer as "The early flash of columnar light"? as in the column of light flashed too early, or it happens early, and beware the flash in general? still amazing, and i know you want to refine it more to carry more meanings... bravo, encore.
annadoc on Sarah's Song by wilco 19 Apr 2006, 2:33 PM
Contemplative. I liked it.
annadoc on A Kiss Beneath The Blossom Tree by Caducus 19 Apr 2006, 2:29 PM
I thought the imagery was very good. I also noted the small edits needed such as (comma after again, before words "my love"), the blossom(s) fell like soft rain, and mis-spelled word incense. I thought this was one of the best poems I've read here.
annadoc on Misplaced Life by Richard 19 Apr 2006, 2:20 PM
I thought this poem had some depth to the verse. gave me pause.
annadoc replying on Story remains the same by annadoc 19 Apr 2006, 2:16 PM
thank you for the thoughts...what I truly need to improve ... and I've been reading others and have to compose my thoughts on those and give my feed back... and I feel I can get some useful inspiration -- I also thought this was a cliche (myself).
Sunny on It destroyed my life by T. Jonathron Remp 19 Apr 2006, 9:50 AM
I know you are trying to get across a deep agony here but, there are certain things I did not like poetically about this piece: the line breaks threw me off with you half-sliced thoughts, the dramatic line indentations that I have no clue as to why those lines in particular are meant to be so emphasized, the -all of a sudden- rhyming scheme plopped into the poem. This poem needs to be clarified & "tidied up" overall a lot in my opinion. ~Sunny
Sunny on Nonchalantly by Plaidypus 19 Apr 2006, 9:41 AM
I liked the way you went "nonchalantly" around your conclusion of becoming anorexic. You told the story, in a way, of the origin of this crippling disease, which I also find quite interesting. Good, clean line breaks. I liked the overall feel of it. You got your point across very clearly & had no problems whatsoever with you clarity. Your poem survived by the way you went around explaining so "nonchalantly" something that has the potential to be deadly, ironically enough. Thanks, Sunny
Ranger on A Bronze Mule by Dovina 19 Apr 2006, 7:14 AM
Good stuff, although it sounds like you limited your market research to one slightly clueless chap. And grace in defeat means that you may feel humble, but never humiliated. Only suggestion is that in the final stanza, put another task after 'row to plow' - makes it fit with the rule of three. Other than that, good story.
Ranger replying on Murder Phoenix Born (meta-villanelle) by Ranger 19 Apr 2006, 7:09 AM
Edit made: 'speckled bone'. It works better than previously.
Dovina replying on In Ethel’s Honor by Dovina 19 Apr 2006, 7:00 AM
You have him pegged. “quietly determined” describes him perfectly. It’s great when somebody understands.
elderking on In Ethel’s Honor by Dovina 19 Apr 2006, 5:13 AM
Ethel had an honorable and loving man in that one... I like the way I can picture him... so quietly determined...his Ethel would have her lily. Very good.
Ranger on rush hour by pollywolly 19 Apr 2006, 1:10 AM
Not sure about using 'roar' so many times, although animalistic I'm sure there are alternatives which carry the same feral weight. Also, 'sand-made' panes. Other than that, I really like the idea in this, describing yourself, I presume, as a small woodland creature watching some savage, lionesque beast. In the main it has great word choice and good imagery.