Lifeboatman
on Buried by Enkidu
6 Apr 2006, 2:16 PM
nice...
This is actually good.. 10!!
It lacks an authentic or vivid setting and tries to compensate for that shortcoming by using empty words. Consider a quick poem:
The day I lay me down to sleep
Never again to wake
I hope to see no loved ones weep
With heavy hearts that break
For I will be in heavenâs land
And sit with God above
A servant at His hand
Receiving all His love
Thereâs nothing wrong with my idea. I want to comfort loved ones so they do not grieve, but rather celebrate. But my poem lacks vision â what heaven might look like, for example, or how a soul feels there. There is no real setting given other than symbolic words.
Rich and vivid, spins a web around the reader ~ you cannot break the silken strands to stop midstream.
You might want to specify Ft Bragg, CA. The Ft Bragg most people know is the gigantic one in North Carolina, home of, among other things, the Delta Force and the most pawn shops per capita anywhere.
Yes!!! This is the good stuff, my friend. I embelishes how I feel so much that I want to read it to certain people and then tell them to "fuck off." There are so many good lines, I'll name some favorites: 3rd line, 2nd stanza...1st line, 3rd stanza...lines 7-8, 4th stanza...and of course the end line is golden. I wouldn't change a thing, I'm giving you a 9.5.
Some people argue that if you crossbreed nature poetry with political poetry, you spawn and breed a mutant - environmental poetry. But most of this rings true, and avoids the preachiness of most environmental attempts.
You have embellished the modern poem "Blueprint" with a tale of yore, which its author may find appalling. But you keep just enough âphotographsâ and modern language to cause wonder as to whether you jest, mimic or jab. Good poem.
Some great phrases and vivid images. But I'd rather see it tied together with transition and clearer flow of the story. It's not a story, but you show sequence, loosely connected.
Thanks, Iâm still thinking I donât need or want the Psalm 23 reference in the title.
I don't rate like that, well, ever since I became a member of this site. Penetrable (I can relate to family suicide as well). Your poem as a whole was brilliantly thought up & scorched onto paper (or post). No more I can say about this except it deserves much better ratings than it has recieved...I can see the incredible talent in this peice.
~Sunny
Thanks for the suggestion on âsquelched.â Iâve changed it to âquenched in the edit, along with some other changes. âbroken bottles,â however, are mixed in with ground-up rock that litters the seas floor.
You are right about the location of Fort Bragg.
Thanks C. Iâve changed it some and have kept Stanza 6, but with changes.
Your imagery is nice, very thoughtful, but you hardly out-Plathed Plath, coming from a Plath researcher & fan (this is not an insult by any means, & I hope you don't interpret it as one). I understand perfectly the concept of a hidden sky-don't see what all the uproar is on that part?? Our styles are a bit similar, so maybe I can just picture the scene clearly with your choice of imagery. The only part I didn't care for was, "For thick on thick air"-I just don't think it adds any elements poetically of thematically. Great theme by the way.
~Sunny
Thanks for the good critique. âVersusâ is right in Stanza 1 of angry verses â blush.
In Stanza 2, âhow it wasâ refers to the old solid cliff, standing obstinately against young belligerent motion of the sea. But I see your point, and have changed it in the edit. I think the new wording also shows that the rock was winning.
In Stanza 4, Iâve changed, âNow memory moved, met solid desire / the ocean going at it still.â to âNow memory moved, met solid desire / armies under different flags.â I think that improves the precision of the changing image as the narrator ages.
In Stanza 6, âgreedâ refers back to âsolid desire,â which is a mild form of greed perhaps. The idea is that memory was winning over the strong desires of younger times. I have changed âgreedâ to âneed,â to make it less jarring. Also, Iâve changed âlittle bitsâ to painful bitsâ â stronger, I think.
Ah, some changes to this! It works fantastically well now, one of your best, I think.
'boken bottles'? I really do need that dyslexia test...
I don't like 'squelched', it doesn't feel poetic enough for this piece. Perhaps 'quenched' would do the trick better?
Love the idea behind this and I love the format, I was expecting rhymes at first but it didn't feel any the worse for being unrhymed.
Now, this might be evidence that I need to take a dyslexia test, but 'many battles passed/some broken rocks' had this wonderful effect of making me also read 'boken bottles', a perfect illustration (to me, at least) of the rocks. Was that intentional?
Great last stanza.
As with your last one, this leaves me longing for a little more description. The ideas are there but this is like a sketch when you want to see a watercolour.
I agree with Dovina about not changing the last line to first person; I'd also suggest losing the exclamation mark...they don't work as well in poetry as they do in prose.
You might want to give us an excerpt from 'Send me the pillow' as well, and use it as the basis for another stanza, maybe?
Very pleasant to read as it is, though.