drnick
on The Perigenetic Prayer by ALChemy
9 Feb 2006, 12:27 PM
Awesome. I like "violets to violence"-that is beautiful. All the lines fit very well together...I don't see where you could make any improvments. The only thing I don't like about this one is how it makes me feel incompitent as a writer. thanks a lot. ;]
Wow, this is really good. I like the 7th line, a very good analogy. There's so much to like, very well written. The part of this poem that is really amazing is how the rythem reflected how I would imagine her dancing: light and skippy, but so very graceful and smooth.
You don't need to be the poet laureate to comment on peoples' works, even if it's just to say whether you liked or disliked what you read. It's nice to know that people have read and thought about what you've written.
As for the poem, I wondered if it might be like that. It's not the most original subject matter but I like the way you've dealt with it - you avoid the cliches, or rather, you take the cliches and rework them well. Now I'm looking at it with more understanding, it's become so much clearer - every line has a definite purpose. I really should have made the connection certain by reading 'the deliberate visitor'. So yes, on both levels it's written well.
2 suggestion: lines 8 and 9 seem a bit worn...it would work better if there was a little more originality there. Also, 'That a journey/Seasons pass...' seems to be a bit of a jump. You might want to consider either putting a break between them or linking it with another line. That's my opinion anyway, others may read it differently.
Useful?
I did mean the double meaning but I think it might have gotten through even if I had used the correct spelling.
If I should learn, in some quite casual way,
That you were gone, not to return again--
Read from the back-page of a paper, say,
Held by a neighbor in a subway train,
How at the corner of this avenue
And such a street (so are the papers filled)
A hurrying man, who happened to be you,
At noon today had happened to be killed--
I should not cry aloud--I could not cry
Aloud, or wring my hands in such a place--
I should but watch the station lights rush by
With a more careful interest on my face;
Or raise my eyes and read with greater care
Where to store furs and how to treat the hair.
- Millay
As far as this poem is concerned it is definately metaphorical:
-The road is a lonely person
-The thick woods is the personality they hide behind
I dunno, maybe you can figure it out from there...I guess the meaning seems obvious to me because I wrote it.
I see, that is a fair request. I suppose I don't make that many comments because I don't really feel as though I know enough to help...but I will try.
Ah, now I thought 'souls' was intentional, it works with the 'prophet shoes' and how the (size 10) prophesy didn't fit, or maybe wasn't fair on, your (size 11) soul - in the same way the shoes didn't fit your feet. Perhaps I read into it a little too much. Still love it though!
I've made 9 hundred and thirty something comments and received 288...you've made 36 comments and received 66. If you want people to talk to you, you have to talk to them first.
Your finest hour.
"whopping great urn" Sounds like a great description for this website.
True, otherwise I'd still be reading it...plus, if you want to hide your poem for two thousand years you won't need a whopping great urn either.
Thanks for the link.
I was looking into the Mary Magdalen stuff a while back. She get's very poetic when she talks about Jesus.
Thank God I kept my poem shorter than that though.
You can have it. Just don't tell them Dovina said Ronald looks like Mohammed.
As usual, beautifully emotive...certainly a talent of yours!
I can almost hear a country guitar and sorrowful hilbilly tune. Nice.
Yes, stanza one could quite easily become the best haiku I've ever seen.
And Iran wonders why the US doesn't want it to have nuclear capability...
I have another one on its way sometime soon...but I just can't get it right...grr
Yes, I'm not good at writing slow poems; this all came to me in a hurry which is I think reflected in the way it turned out.
Thanks for having a read, everyones' comments are (as always) much appreciated!