poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 11621–11640 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

AuntyM replying on In praise of racism by INTRANSIT 23 Jan 2006, 2:31 PM
It is such a shame we are not all as perfect as "Dovina". Maybe, it is all the world traveling that she does? Maybe, she just has a history of being perfect? Maybe, she has NO idiosyncrasies? Maybe her "shtick" is up her...! My advice: Order Szechwan...and a life!
ALChemy replying on When God is Needed No More by ALChemy 23 Jan 2006, 2:30 PM
Yes, I think my usual smooth rhythm has become almost an expected part of my poems. I only wrote it yesterday and quite quickly I might say. I had just finished reading Blake's Songs of Experience after reading Songs of Innocence and this is what came out of me. I wasn't sure if the meter narrowed too much near the end or not so I'm glad you caught that. Yeah, I missed that damn "," when I put the "and" in. Good eye. The last 4 lines were the heart of the poem so I'm a little disappointed the you didn't care fore them. Still, thanks for the input D.
Dovina on My Hand of god by drnick 23 Jan 2006, 2:23 PM
This is really good, and vindicates the one who I thought might be a psycho in your last poem. I especially like Verse 2 because it conveys in a very subtle way something I've heard said in very preachy texts and to less effect.
Dovina replying on In praise of racism by INTRANSIT 23 Jan 2006, 2:16 PM
Me too.
Dovina on When God is Needed No More by ALChemy 23 Jan 2006, 2:15 PM
Recently, you told me you were happy that a new poem I had posted was not about God. Had to chuckle. This has a nice rhythm at the start, which seems to crumble a bit toward the end. A climax comes at, "Could we not then go on godless?" Of course I could say you are preaching, not showing, but I like preaching sometimes, and this is not too preachy. I understand "Surely such reward’s deserved" to mean "reward is" but "surely He deserves reward" sounds better to me. "For it is in God’s plan" seems like it needs "good" or something before "plan" for rhythm's sake. "and to send forth his good children" seems bland, I dunno. Try "some" in "Nor dream truth of any hereafter" instead of "any." The lone period after "best" seems awkward, it's the only one; likewise the comma after "wisdom." "that sees"? - try "who sees".
ALChemy on Gaze by AuntyM 23 Jan 2006, 2:08 PM
Nice haiku by the way.
ALChemy on Gaze by AuntyM 23 Jan 2006, 2:07 PM
I've noticed the return of a lot of long time gone rankers lately. What, did you all get locked up for a couple years or something?
ALChemy replying on In praise of racism by INTRANSIT 23 Jan 2006, 1:49 PM
I thought the way it layed out the whole text for you was great. I saved it in my favorites for that reason alone.
Dovina replying on In praise of racism by INTRANSIT 23 Jan 2006, 1:44 PM
Yeah, that's pretty good. It missed "traveling" though, and showed me "schtick" can have a "ck" or just a "k".
ALChemy on In praise of racism by INTRANSIT 23 Jan 2006, 1:32 PM
Dovina on In praise of racism by INTRANSIT 23 Jan 2006, 10:44 AM
I suppose there’s no spell checkers in truck stops, so I’ll forgive “traveling” “hsitory's” “idiosyncracies” “schtick” and “Sechuan.” The funky spacing is a little harder.
Dovina on A Schizophrenic by amanda_dcosta 23 Jan 2006, 10:34 AM
Sorry for my comment on your last one. I see now that you do want critique, and so I’ll give it. First, the basics: “unkept” should be “unkempt” I think, just to be traditional. And “labeled” should be “labeled.” Now for the gritty: “Mood, not his best, he lives his life, a real test” How does living his life as a test relate to his current mood? Maybe you did it like that just for the rhyme and to sound poetic. That's a blunt conclusion, and I'll retract if you show me how the sentence says something important. The following sentence, “Alas . . .” is a little sermon that could be better shown. (Actually, the last three verses are a sermon, and that’s not bad, except that I think giving more reasons for your conclusions would make them more palatable.) The next sentence, “He’s crying . . .” is better, but “want” should be “wants.”
Prince of Void on May I Help by Dovina 23 Jan 2006, 10:18 AM
I love how you drew me thorogh the joy of poetry that's beauty goes to my heart..and I contact ur feelings are restless thorough ur poems
ALChemy on Temporary moments by Prince of Void 23 Jan 2006, 10:13 AM
Griefs not grieves in line 1. Use a double line space instead of "..." after "Still you" Lose the "..." after "All this time what I have done". Either "through millions of tears fallen on This ocean of time. It can be something to see me now" or- "though a million tears has fallen on This ocean of time, it can be something to see me now" You are definately improving though.
ALChemy on In praise of racism by INTRANSIT 23 Jan 2006, 9:11 AM
Brilliant and witty. Yes we have been playing a fools game haven't we. You flip-flopped the "is" in "history".
ALChemy on A Schizophrenic by amanda_dcosta 23 Jan 2006, 8:58 AM
This is nice writing but I wished you would have approached it differently. I wish you would've written it in a schizo manner. Like- "He snakes his head, they're in his bed, gibbergarberish. With eyes deep red. he fights and kicks, they shout and spit, And take his family Into their midst. With unhair kept, mood, damnedest He rights his life by hr.-ly tests"... For more of an idea see schizo poet Ernst Herbeck: http://garysullivan.blogspot.com/2005/11/three-more-ernst-herbeck-translations.html http://www.fascicle.com/issue01/Poets/herbeck1.htm
ALChemy on My Hand of god by drnick 23 Jan 2006, 8:09 AM
It'd make a good lyric.
AngelicVampiress on Topper Fey by ALChemy 23 Jan 2006, 8:06 AM
*8* =)
ALChemy on On Golden Bond by jmalone 23 Jan 2006, 8:03 AM
Lose all the "On Golden Pond" references(i.e. Title and last line of stanza 1)and you've got yourself a really good poem.
ALChemy replying on Jailbird by zodiac 22 Jan 2006, 10:51 PM
She probably just thought you were looking at dirty pictures on the internet:)