zodiac
replying on Racism 4 by Dovina
18 Jan 2006, 10:24 AM
http://www.alsopreview.com/gaz/lessons/plpoet.html
The statement is too true, but the poem is crap.
Some very good lines in here, although a lot of the verses seem to be built around this lines, condensing it could improve the experience for people like me.
You have put such minimal thought into this poem, and such minimal effort into making it a poem.
Interesting as a story, but the repetition of words to be creepy comes off making it sound like it should be read to scare children on halloween.
So...
This is hardly the place to worry about sounding unsympathetic.
Tell her what you think. Even if she won't change this poem your ideas may effect the next poem she writes. Anybody who complains about valid negetive criticism as being cruel is a total pussy.
Dont know the history of the drafts but dont care its one of those poems which moves me.
That rarely happens.
My God man, you left out some of the best parts:
http://www.alsopreview.com/gaz/lessons/p ldonts.html
I think he nails all our asses at least once with the many cliches he exposes.
Oh, if only I could express how great this truly is. *11*
This could have been much better, still, *7*
Hah, this is pretty damn good, and I don't care at all about what you have to say. *9*
I don't know why, but I like this.P-e-rish *7*
I feel like I can relate to this one, I like it a lot.
Amanda, I hate being the referee who calls an unpopular foul, but thatâs how I feel. You have posted a poem, written in a time of sorrow, that you say you do not intend to edit and which you admit needs editing. I take the poem as heartfelt sentiment for a wonderful grandmother, and for that it is a good poem. But I think the âfoulâ comes when you post it on a site for voting and commenting, because there is little a commenter can say without sounding unsympathetic, and to vote low is show lack of sympathy for your feelings or lack of appreciation for your grandmother. Hope you understand.