poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 12021–12040 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

zodiac on Intestinal Splash by cyan9 11 Jan 2006, 9:32 AM
Overkill.
zodiac replying on The chestnut by richa 11 Jan 2006, 7:39 AM
The missed out repetition. It was really, um, drunk sounding that way. And I can't remember what exactly you had after "and the girl" in the first stanza, but I think it was more lyrical.
pollywolly on The copper man and Labrador by Caducus 11 Jan 2006, 7:35 AM
really enjoyed this piece. i think you have captured human nature so perfectly and showed it so well in contrast with the love of the pet. very well written.
richa replying on The chestnut by richa 11 Jan 2006, 3:39 AM
I agree but I wanted to shake off its regimented shape. Is it the bits I missed out that ruin it or the new form.
richa replying on Tulip by richa 11 Jan 2006, 3:34 AM
I'm not entirely happy but it has been a while so I thought I'd put one on p/r. How about the first two lines. I meant 'that' as in 'for it is the case' as a way to explain the statement 'he has poor taste'. Does it need punctuation between l1 and l2.
richa replying on Uncontrolled scribblings one luch break by Nicholas Jones 11 Jan 2006, 3:27 AM
I've been doing the same as Nicholas the Jones. That and trolling the internet on messageboards which is great fun and a terrible waste of my evenings.
cyan9 on Comment on Avian 'flu by Stephen Robins 11 Jan 2006, 1:16 AM
You bastard
zodiac replying on She Crab by http://mulberryfairy 10 Jan 2006, 9:30 PM
So's the crab, for that. And they're both from Eliot. But I bet you knew that.
http://mulberryfairy replying on She Crab by http://mulberryfairy 10 Jan 2006, 9:08 PM
the too too solid flesh is an allusion to Shakespeare- it is about suffering- of being alive and in pain rather than dead and in peace. I think it was from Hamlet.
http://mulberryfairy replying on She Crab by http://mulberryfairy 10 Jan 2006, 9:06 PM
I attempted to set it up with the title (SHE crab)- the crab is a she, but the child is noticeably genderless- never referred to with any pronoun.
http://mulberryfairy replying on Untitled by http://mulberryfairy 10 Jan 2006, 9:03 PM
not that explaining it to you makes it explanatory enough to be a good read, but the thing is, dreaming his death protects "the narrator" from his having power over her (through her love for him).
well done- we had one of those bright days today
http://mulberryfairy on The chestnut by richa 10 Jan 2006, 8:30 PM
"Dates have become misaligned or places" I didn't get the "or places" The rest is great.
http://mulberryfairy on Tulip by richa 10 Jan 2006, 8:26 PM
seems like you are forcing some words in here for the sake of your meter- the poor tulip boy has poor taste "that" he loves... (for?)(as?)that doesn't seem to be the right definitive article. Ignoring your meter, I would take out the "that" completely, then remove the "ands" in the 3rd and 4th lines. with neither purse nor name (why so many articles?) I like the dichotomy of him loving his plot, but being on a wage- puzzling.
http://mulberryfairy on Suck by MacFrantic 10 Jan 2006, 8:16 PM
whose dirge- I got lost there- she is dead and therefore belied to your aliveness?
http://mulberryfairy on Flow by zodiac 10 Jan 2006, 8:09 PM
beautiful, nice word choices
mission accomplished- you made a mundane subject into a dance
http://mulberryfairy replying on I, Ann Boleyn by http://mulberryfairy 10 Jan 2006, 7:59 PM
good call, thanks
zodiac on Witch's Brew by ecargo 10 Jan 2006, 7:09 PM
This got better. First stanza needs a rewrite.
zodiac on Daylight at Dawn by D. $ Fontera 10 Jan 2006, 7:07 PM
Of all the things just for rhyme in this one, "if not to read one more?" is the most worrisome.