poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 12461–12480 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

elderking replying on when i met sky alone by Prince of Void 2 Jan 2006, 2:28 PM
actually it wasn't the first line that caught my interest it was liine 2 & 3. . .both are keepers. The last line left me feeling like "what? is that all there is?"
Prince of Void on Claim to Call by MacFrantic 2 Jan 2006, 12:37 PM
silence of memories haunted ur poem ...nice job
Depressing. Take a long walk.
Dovina replying on Romans 8:28 by amanda_dcosta 2 Jan 2006, 12:10 PM
Fuzzy logic: 1. I'm taller than everybody. 2. My brother is six feet tall. 3. Therefore, I'm taller than my brother. The fuzzy-logic word here is “therefore.” Without it, No. 3 would be perfectly logical, and your assertion of its illogic absurd. But “therefore” is not totally illogical since it works with Statement 1, and No.2 is irrelevant. Read it without No. 2, and it means the same thing. Illogic: Dovina is a moron because she cites 1 + 1 = 2 as evidence for a logical God.
amanda_dcosta on Romans 8:28 by amanda_dcosta 2 Jan 2006, 9:48 AM
How deep are the depths of the riches and the wisdom and the knowledge of God!
ALChemy replying on Romans 8:28 by amanda_dcosta 2 Jan 2006, 9:00 AM
Your answer: That's my point. Then why believe in him? Your answer: I don't know. 'Cause it makes you feel good. Thank you Zodiac I now believe God must exist. Human logic is limited. Ultimate knowledge is God. Forgive me if I sought both. Goodbye human logic, goodbye.
ALChemy replying on Romans 8:28 by amanda_dcosta 2 Jan 2006, 8:33 AM
Happy Jan. 2 Zodiac.
ALChemy replying on Romans 8:28 by amanda_dcosta 2 Jan 2006, 8:29 AM
Then why bother looking for him at all?
ALChemy replying on Romans 8:28 by amanda_dcosta 2 Jan 2006, 8:19 AM
First of all I didn't mean it as an insult. There aren't many people with your education that don't totally let it go to their heads. Sheesh! Second I was a pool shark once and metaphorically speaking I only said that you were willing to ease up on your game a little so that you didn't leave others feeling insufficient. You know, 'cause you're such a nice guy and all.
zodiac on Desperate Season by Sisterwolf 2 Jan 2006, 7:58 AM
Hm, I like your more modern-voiced poems a little better. But kudos for the title and Richard III reference. I'm with Dovina: the transition from winter to full summer needs more transitioning. Yes, it's jarring and juxtaposed. No, I don't think that helps the poem. Otherwise, good. I'm glad you stuck around after all.
zodiac on Body & Earth by PoeticXTC 2 Jan 2006, 7:53 AM
Insane is misspelled. Very funny.
INTRANSIT replying on Nightfall by Niphredil 2 Jan 2006, 7:51 AM
My dic. says that it also means: Dark;dim. I'm guessing She went with darkling for flow/beat reasons.
zodiac on MEANinglessness by lmp 2 Jan 2006, 7:51 AM
Say "fucking". Or, better yet, don't use swear-words (or half-swear-words) at all. This beating-around-the-bush is kind of wack.
zodiac replying on Nightfall by Niphredil 2 Jan 2006, 7:46 AM
> "Darkling" means "in the dark." No it doesn't.
zodiac replying on Nightfall by Niphredil 2 Jan 2006, 7:44 AM
Oh, actually nothing. I didn't remember reading it and just kind of assumed it had some. Sorry, Niphredil. This is a great poem. I don't know what Dovina's problem is.
zodiac on broodmood by lmp 2 Jan 2006, 7:42 AM
Any poem with the word "scudding" in it gets an extra point from me.
zodiac on we hold hands when i sleep by hendrimike 2 Jan 2006, 7:41 AM
Rewrite all of this so it's like the fourth verse.
INTRANSIT replying on Nightfall by Niphredil 2 Jan 2006, 7:40 AM
Well, what exactly is the illogic in Nephs poem. the word darkling? Perhaps it's the pale glow in s-2 that leads us awry? I personally see no problem here.
zodiac replying on Nightfall by Niphredil 2 Jan 2006, 7:33 AM
I was trying to keep you from giving a poemranker post for an answer. Kerouac seems perfectly logical to me, mostly because reporting stream-of-consciousness is a perfectly logical thing to do, and that's obviously what Kerouac's doing. Yes, something like your quote above (or this one: "The taste / of rain / —Why kneel?") makes loose, unlogical "conclusions". But compare that with Niphredil's poem here and you can see how Kerouac gets away with it and Niphredil doesn't. And anyway, a great way to get around having to be logical in poetry is to say 'I'm a Beat Poet' three times, then spin around and vanish.