ALChemy
on Close To The Beginning by RawPunkGirl
13 Nov 2005, 9:17 PM
Fro the 1st stanza of Billy Collins' "Nightclub":
You are so beautiful and I am a fool
to be in love with you
is a theme that keeps coming up
in songs and poems.
There seems to be no room for variation.
I have never heard anyone sing
I am so beautiful
and you are a fool to be in love with me,
even though this notion has surely
crossed the minds of women and men alike.
You are so beautiful, too bad you are a fool
is another one you don't hear.
Or, you are a fool to consider me beautiful.
That one you will never hear, guaranteed.
Line 6: 'Withstand the beat of time' seemed out of place to me...
Could you explain how this ends the first stanza?
I find it very odd that I see you on multiple websites.
And i'm not even a stalker.
On another note:
Line 3: I think that 'Being dressed in my best...' should be changed. Keep the idea, but change the wording so it doesn't rhyme. Because it sounds horrible.
overall, though, I thought it was ok.
She might be saying people will pay to cure themselves when they're sick, but not to eliminate disease altogether when it doesn't affect them. Like eliminating the "minor 5" diseases in Africa (malaria, typhoid, and I forget the rest), which kill more Africans than AIDS but would require a smaller investment to totally eliminate than what we currently spend fighting AIDS in Africa.
I will agree to the rightness of one whom I generally accuse of placing rhythm above rightness.
It would be okay except for the last stanza switching back to present again. I think it would be even better all in present, "The howl of tires sinks" and so on. I feel justified in answering here because that was my crit too and I want to show I can be nice.
Iâve been trying to stop howling for years, but it keeps welling up uncontrollably.
I see how "like pebbles, city deep" improves rhythm, and in this case I may follow you there, though it goes against gut desire for meaning.
And my But in the ass end of this, yes that too should go, I think.
so much for context, eh?