Dovina
replying on The Servant and The Messenger by ALChemy
10 Oct 2005, 6:21 PM
You began by saying, "This is a philosopher: 'I believe X.'" But belief is not philosophy, and there you go astray. Add and retract addendums all day, it won't help.
The point is, (and it should be obvious) that you're argueing about nonsense while I'm trying to make a serious point. You argue with a statements like "Evolution made dogs" because you can't understand the wording. It's the same as saying "chance made dogs," dogs were made by chance" or "by chance, dogs were made." These statements all mean the same thing. Can we leave this trivial aside at that?
Really?
Beatiful... I wish I was you under the chestnut, bonin that girl.
I'm researching. back in a minute.
whoda thunk just friendly needling could make a poem, ha!
If I only knw gambling jargon.....
PS-It may be possible to say instead "phenomena made us, but to no purpose". But what's the point?
I've gotta run, so I'll sum up.
DOVINA: Evolution isn't sentient. It made us.
ZODIAC: Evolution isn't a thing capable of making. It's a theory, a way of rationalizing phenomena. You're like saying the metric system made centimeters (or, better, it made distance).
DOVINA: Evolution isn't sentient. It made us.
ZODIAC: Urggh.
'Built' implies builder. 'Made' implies maker. No difference if there's purpose or not.
If you're going to argue with anything, argue with that. But I wouldn't recommend it.
Yes, but I haven't claimed to define philosophy or philsophers (not on this poem, at least.) I said 'A philosopher says X, a religious says Y', only.
You can argue I've said "A person who says 'I believe X' is a philsopher", but even that's not much of a leg to stand on.
And for that, it works. A philosopher does say, I believe X. So does a religious sometime. But a religious also says, I believe in a philosophy (and, NEW ADDENDUM) a philosopher doesn't.
I retract my first addendum and all your argument from the beginning is moot.
Why are so absurd as to say that I think evolution is intelligent. I simply said that it might have made us that way. Not on purpose, because it has no purpose. But it might have done it anyway. It's the same thing as saying it might have occurred by chance to anyone but you.
I thought this poem was going to be about how a pentigram is enigmatic. I see you've kept clear of that. And everything else enigmatic, apparently.
I laughed and and sympathized. Bar talk is almost spiritual at times, almost like church.
Yes, it does. And the way you say it does, too.
For the last time, evolution didn't build us. Evolution didn't have us in mind when it started. Evolution is not a sentient being or a process capable of predicting itself the way, say, scientists sometimes predict it. Scientists did not build us. Scientists did not create evolution. Scientists have had no control over evolution to date, and have very little now. Speaking of any process by which humans are "built" (excluding the process of God or gods creating the earth) is about equivalent to saying, I don't know, the universe or undersea ridges are "built". If you persist in using the term "built" for things which don't (according to me) involve a sentient builder, I must persist in considering you a religious and, consequently, ignoring you.
If you've got to say something about the matter, try something like this:
A set of myriad circumstances has resulted (meaning, at the present moment) in the so-called dominant species on Earth having a tendency to develop faiths and to afterwards wonder about such matters as whether it was built to develop faith.
No, the whole addended idea sucks. Philosophy is not "I believe X." Philosophers argue about the definition of philosophy, but yours is definiteloy not up for contention.
Yes, I thikk it might have gone something like that. All it proves is that we're built to develop faith. Maybe pure evolution made us that way. It doesn't imply intelligent design.
Heh, heh. Wide open.