poemranker ::20 most recent comments by Blue Magpie (101-120) and replies

Comments byBlue Magpie, 101–120 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

I actually found this quite interesting and poetic although I have to wonder just exactly where it is supposed to be. I will read it again.
on Tiredness by kawakurdi 15 Dec 2004, 12:35 AM
Interesting, 'snaps' seems wrong somehow. Do try and cheer up.
on exercise by JoyLuck 15 Dec 2004, 12:33 AM
A poem that passes judgement on itself is a novelty, if not a very good one.
replying on Forsaken Love by Blue Magpie 15 Dec 2004, 12:29 AM
Thanks for your comments, I am sorry you are unable to see what the poem is about, but please don't assume that because you haven't seen something yet that it doesn't exist, this is a route that prohibits learning
on Peptalk in the Dugout by Dovina 14 Dec 2004, 5:17 AM
A nice read, I think it is batter's box however. Personally I think it would be more catching with rhymes, but then I am biased.
on You and Me at Boulder Lake by jessicazee 14 Dec 2004, 5:13 AM
I liked the last 1.5 lines the best. The toenail of God doesn't seem to harmonise, and I fail to understand why most of the line breaks are where they are. But it was an interesting read.
on The Grey Prince Of Gulls by Caducus 14 Dec 2004, 1:58 AM
Some interesting imagery
on Solitude by Dovina 13 Sep 2004, 10:02 PM
Dear Dovina,
While this is obviously a pretty picture the language usage does not appear to be very poetic to meeither in its use of metaphor etc, or in its imagery presentation, and there is not rhyme or rhythm. "A picture in Phi" what does this offer us phi "Φ" being the 21st letter of the Greek alphabet, the Greek equivalent of "F", a circle with a line through it, doesn't inspire me with images relevent to seashells or hermit crabs or solitude. So I am sorry but I just don't see the poetry here, just prose.
on Eurydice by unknown 11 Sep 2004, 10:22 PM
This would make a nice song actually
replying on Edges by Blue Magpie 8 Sep 2004, 10:41 PM
Hi Wilco,
Thanks for the welcome. Its been a while since I have visited here, or anywhere. I have rewritten the above a good deal since posting it, although the more intelligent feedback came from elsewhere.
on New Year by emilyowey 8 Sep 2004, 5:57 AM
Perhaps a touch self-pitying and a little open to personal interpretation, vagueness and subtlety are not the same thing.
on New Year by emilyowey 8 Sep 2004, 5:57 AM
Perhaps a touch self-pitying and a little open to personal interpretation, vagueness and subtlety are not the same thing.
on New Year by emilyowey 8 Sep 2004, 5:57 AM
Perhaps a touch self-pitying and a little open to personal interpretation, vagueness and subtlety are not the same thing.
on Sunrise by TLRufener 8 Sep 2004, 5:52 AM
The line "Once more I sleep none" is so ungrammatic it pretty much ruins the rest of the poem, some punctuation would also help.
on Director's Cut by New Life Drug 6 Sep 2004, 7:37 AM
Dear NLD,
It is very nice to see something positive being said. As a poem however this lacks that something extra in language usage to really raise it above prose. Also things like we were standing.... when suddenly you appeared, as there are really only the two of you in this story one is left wondering who the first we applies to if 'you' were not there, or how you could have been there and then appeared. All told I think you have a core here but you need to work on it some. Cut, prune and shape it a bit.
replying on Edges by Blue Magpie 6 Sep 2004, 7:30 AM
Sliver,
Thanks for stopping by, and for enjoying thepoem, it is not finished, I am working on another stanza now relating to belief.
replying on Edges by Blue Magpie 6 Sep 2004, 7:29 AM
Dear Dovina,
Thank you for your kind words. However the criticism is a bit vague, could you possibly tell me exactly where you think I have sacrificed meaning for prose. The same goes for the comment on follow-through for rhythm, but I also have difficulty knowing what you mean by follow-through, previous to this I have only heard the term used in sports training, tennis etc.
on Stand Up For Yourself !!! by Brandy_n_Cali 5 Sep 2004, 9:58 PM
Further more you have not really said anything new, which means you have to say it in a memorable way to make your effort worth while, communication and especially poetry is not just ideas in words, but ideas/feelings in words that are well used, shaped and polished like a gem until they shine.
on A Poem by BigB 5 Sep 2004, 9:54 PM
I also think a better title, or more clarification in the poem would be in order.
on The Conqueror Worm by zodiac 5 Sep 2004, 9:53 AM
Spreading Sturm und drang across two lines looks very poor, you ae breaking aconcept where no concept should be broken, still there is some nice imagery here, made me remember being an undergraduate.