poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 44181–44200 back. Include replies to comments

<~> on broken nail by blackball 27 Dec 2002, 11:52 PM
what does the primal clawing have to do with the street lamp's light? can you please make a nice neat package out of this one?
<~> on solitorus by glittalogik 27 Dec 2002, 11:54 PM
freshly said, but feels unfinished
SP REYNOLDS on The Coming Light by poetandknowit 27 Dec 2002, 11:30 PM
Than please don't waste my time by commenting on something above you...Maybe take another class and let a professor tell you how to think.
<~> on plain by blackball 27 Dec 2002, 11:39 PM
L1 &L2--you don't need both 'by myself' and 'solitary'. L4: change to 'as days fluttered past' i believe that's what p&k and h8 are suggesting, and i agree.
<~> on frontage by xanthippe 27 Dec 2002, 11:50 PM
give me something i can hold on to
<~> on im playing basketball by rockinindividual 27 Dec 2002, 11:58 PM
i would like to see more basketball argot in this poem. i want you to name sports stuff, and with each slamdunk, or 3pointshot, or whatever--you erase a little bit more of the weight of the anger. balance the scales of action and reaction. you dig?
SP REYNOLDS on The Coming Light by poetandknowit 27 Dec 2002, 10:50 PM
I feel battered and bruised. My left lip is swollen from your harness. Do you have a boner? "gunna" is the obvious mispelling of "going to..." which means whatever you yourself as a qualified reader understand it to mean. An inability to bend words is an inability for morphology. If you need to know what that word means, reply back, and I'll allow you to know.
<~> on some deleted poem 27 Dec 2002, 11:13 PM
this is a phenomenal image: And what was control would fall Like mercury to the ground but, i hate this line: I am a simple gal bringing on a testy madness it's out of character with the rest of the poem, i think. there are a couple of other places where the unevenness shows as well. you create magnificent visuals, and then throw in some homespun, and it loses its magic. see what i mean, mrs.g?
<~> on some deleted poem 27 Dec 2002, 11:26 PM
so, very, many, commas, interrupt, the, flow, of, this, and, make, it feel, like, a, list, poem. and it is not. it's a nicely concocted metaphor for pain--although the maggots are a bit of a stretch: freshly spurting blood does not maggots produce--they imple a length of time has passed, which it clearly has not, because the action of this poem happens in an instant. also, i take issue with her 'spitting' out the words. wouldn't she be treacly-sweet, just to twist the blade a little deeper? with some minor refinements, this could be superb.
SP REYNOLDS on The Coming Light by poetandknowit 27 Dec 2002, 11:53 PM
First of all, have I sent you for a loop? Are you questioning if I am actually a different person than Horus8. I am. Is your mind not allowing you to sleep at night due to something so trivial (something besides your poetry that is)as that? Do you have a poster of Robert Frost on your wall...Or is it Jose Cansaco? Your identity crisis scares me...Your becoming psychotic, if so your amongst a history of poets. The only difference is, we can write and are also published. But that doesn't matter...you have poemranker.
poetandknowit on some deleted poem 27 Dec 2002, 10:08 PM
Damn. Just damn. I have decided that you and z should be lovers. Are you available? And when you inspire each other I shall come watch just for the sake of voyeurism. The East must be miserable this time of year, because you guys are kicking out the jams. Again, I will read later and think, think, think.
god'swife on corners by rockinindividual 27 Dec 2002, 9:59 PM
I read this last, you make reading these easy and enjoyable. There are some small things that might do better if they were changed, But the telling, the telling is almost flawless. I like your poems.
poetandknowit on Your sacrifice by Crakyamuni 27 Dec 2002, 10:42 PM
I watched my aunt's apartment complex burn to the ground at Christmastime when I was six. My step-grandfather knocked a candle into a trashcan in the bathroom. That is what started the whole shebang. Some say he did it on purpose. He was an outsider in the family. I think it went on behind backs for years. But he is dead now. I remember sitting on the swings at the little playground there watching the whirl of the fire truck lights and the flames wild twist and turns and families running all over the place and my family and my aunt all crying and hugging each other and praising the lord, which I thought was odd considering the situation, and I thought it was the coolest thing ever. Unlike this poem.
poetandknowit on some deleted poem 27 Dec 2002, 9:03 PM
Interesting but awkward grammar, but as hurus8 says: that does not really matter. And you dislike the academic side of things. But is is awkward and staggers the flow of things from the get go I guess you are in the erotic business now. The Secret Life of Catherine M.. The belly as a plain of wheat is just down right funny. Does that mean hairy. Then you switch context. From direct to third. Do you start to talk directly to the pecker? There are some nice lines here and the idea is sound, but some of the images border on comical. Bur your bud thinks it is the best poem you have ever written, so that is all that matters. If I was your writing teacher I would ask you if you think about your words. Really think about them? Is this supposed to be funny?
poetandknowit on some deleted poem 27 Dec 2002, 9:13 PM
Oh my god, there are two of them. This is much less comic and again has some nice lines. Unprententiously - wow I cannot say have ever read this in a poem. And I suppose there is a reason for that. Creating a following of one - I like this. And the frist line. Good stuff.
poetandknowit on Things by Quarton 27 Dec 2002, 9:21 PM
Put the Pete Singer down and step away from the poem. I feel like I am reading a generic mantra read before a march of protest to Ted Nugent's United Sportsmen of America Headquarters in Michigan during the opening days of hunting season. You know, there is good fiction out there on this movement. Read "My Year of Meats" by Ruth, shit I cannot find the book anywhere in all these piles. Fuck. Well anyway, look it up. It tackles the subject with a bit of originality, whereas this falls into sap.
poetandknowit on Brackish by <~> 27 Dec 2002, 10:05 PM
Your images are wonderful. Just wonderful. The first stanza..wow. Let me think on this one a bit, read it a few more times and send along some thoughts.
poetandknowit on plain by blackball 27 Dec 2002, 10:46 PM
Make it active rather than passive for staters. "nothing" to anything.
poetandknowit on some deleted poem 27 Dec 2002, 9:15 PM
This is beyond bad. "gunna"? What the hell is "gunna"?
SP REYNOLDS on some deleted poem 27 Dec 2002, 10:27 PM
My editor, oh yes, yes My publishing dreams have come true!