Skamper
on Rolling Bells by MacFrantic
31 May 2007, 9:07 AM
molesting - dragging - torturing, and all things associated with the living...so visual here. Still not entirely sure this has clicked in its meaning with me, but I get lost in the movement within.
just to counterbalance Edna's vote.
The imagery and flow is magnificent. I agree with nypoet however that the self reflection stanzas should be entirely cut. They detroy everything that you build before. Keep stanzas 1,2,3,7,8,9,10 and leave the rest unchanged.
(I'm sorry, that seat is taken.) great line - work back from there and shorten your sentences - pull it all in tight and the image will just pop...
I get the feel of emo - but the cuz in the last line doesn't fit with the rest of the write. You could lose it and keep with the darkness, it lightens the write too much - almost childish.
"I watched your sideview-mirror split
into a thousand glassy pieces,
like the sparkly spray from
sneezing in the sunlight."
My fav description - and like these lines, movement and colour follows in every thing you've written.
sometimes you just hit it...thanx
Well kind of an ode, only in the sense it's a dedication I guess. I know what your saying with internal rhymes giving a kick and work the flow...I will work on this, when I get over myself...a week or so should do it...
thanks..."chained in their vanity" - hmmm...I can see it working in my head...wanna look? Can't explain it any other way, maybe except to say that most poets refuse to learn, thinking what they write is as vivid as van gogh's Irises, when in reality they dabble with fingerpaint...*shrugs*
darylchew
replying on Close your eyes but keep your mind wide open by darylchew
28 May 2007, 9:41 AM
the poem is about death and loss and how a person copes
Seems like some graphic image written in C++. Otherwise, what is the title about?
numb with self-denial - doesn't show much. And it tries to tell something, but what?
ââBovine eyesâ sounds wretched.â I used âbovineâ to avoid what I thought was the wretched sound of âcows.â Maybe I made it wretcheder.
ââFree from fence and milkingâ sounds terribly clunky.â I admit to often sounding clunky. The sound of poems is a thing Iâm working on.
âWhat is wrong with she pants (UP) a lonely hill instead of lying in the shade.â Thatâs a good suggestion; better than the way I had it. I donât like âupâ though â sounds clunky. Iâll change it to âshe pants a lonely hill / instead of lying in the shade.â
âAnthropomorphism is dodgy at the best of times but even if we attribute thoughts to the cow, why would it assume from seeing a human cycle up a hill that she was 'free from milking'â Those bovine eyes stare at me with the provincial look of someone who always lives by the norms and never ventures. Such a person complains about the milking tubes her owner attaches to her tits twice a day and about the fence that holds her in, but she never really wants it any other way, because thatâs how dairy cows live.
âFrom their perspective you are behind a fence too.â From their perspective, I am free from the fence, which they know every inch of.
âThe cows rebukedâ Maybe I didnât make it clear, but the cows are not rebuking, the cyclist is. She preaches to the cows - a daft idea, perhaps, but each to their own.
âI would say in the alcohol of afternoon, then you have a metaphor for the weariness and blurriness. As it stands it reads that legs draw concentration like alcohol draws concentration.â Actually, that is what I mean. Working legs draw blood from the brain, which in the weariness of afternoon, after cycling most of the day, has an effect on the brain similar to drunkenness. Still, I like the way you phrase it. Iâll change it to âIn the alcohol of afternoon, / legs draw concentration,â
Thanks for your comments.
I also find the discussion about articles interesting. Iâll take your comments one at a time:
âOn country road in mid-Virginiaâ Maybe itâs an American preference, but I think âaâ shows that it could be any country road, where no article implies some particular road called âcountry.â
âThe cyclist pulls up another hillâ You are right in saying that the cyclist is a particular person and that she does not pull a hill, but rather ascends it or pulls up it. The cyclist is, as you say, at the center of the poem, so on that basis I could agree that âtheâ should be used. You say that she is ânot just a cyclist,â but really she is. I want to show her as nothing great or worthy of separation from other cyclists.
âPast the house with mammoth lawn. The use of 'the' here specifies that the house is a landmark rather than just any house with big lawn.â But really it is just another house with a big lawn. The country people of Virginia take pride in their lawns. Sometimes I pass a run-down house trailer with three acres of mowed grass and a fine garden.
âVisual input does not soothe tired eyes.â I often find the opposite to be true when cycling. The sight of a well-kept dairy farm soothes the strain on my eyes that has come from staring on the road, avoiding death by coal truck or passing car.
âthe cows look up,â Here I agree that the cows are almost as central to the poem as the cyclist, but they are not particular cows, and therefore the definite article âtheâ seems inappropriate.
darylchew
replying on Close your eyes but keep your mind wide open by darylchew
28 May 2007, 7:58 AM
alright! got that line off bridge to terabithia, sort of a reply to the movie.
poor word choice by me. i meant it was cliche and the rest of the poem would be better off without it.
as if were?
erstwhile kelp?
some of these choices of phrase need rethinking.
does this contain a note of regret?
the last stanza should be split into two lines. i like the ending, but for it to have the impact i think you want, you have to introduce the coil image earlier. 'intricate architecture' could be improved upon to tie the beginning and end together.
for awhile i thought this was about new jersey - the garden state... but yes, the first two lines seem unnecessary.