Jill Stockinger
on Arm 'n' headin (Mr.Mexicacco) by suprembeaner
22 Dec 2020, 5:06 PM
Annoying
(stampede of cattle, not stamped of cattle)
Cannot conceive of how a wave "suede"s- swayed? What?
Oversized- one word- aftertaste, one word. Do your proofreading before submitting. " a cornucopia" not an cornucopia. "What we'll do tomorrow? Not "What will do". Too many errors detracted from enjoying the poem.
Annoyed by so many misspellings. If they were deliberate, they were not useful. Some interesting ideas, imagery
Reads like headlines but it gripped me all the way through. Love how "Tom" lines and "Mary" are interspersed here and there. You would not think such a poem would work but I think it does! Enjoyed this! Remembered reading some of these...it engaged my thought, had some humor, did make me think! Enjoyable.
Some beautiful lines, good ending, like how you carry the idea throughout the poem, the speaker believing the person who killed herself is so much better than he is, right to a very bitter end.....
Some good lines, I like the idea captured.
No comma after "Hunts gone by" I think-
some clunky lines: "experiences, good and bad"-
some very good lines: "sing to my soul of ages gone by" and "Ageless you stand, tall and proud/ Lichen grows upon your surfaces"; uneven rhyme scheme does not help (1st and 4th lines in first stanza, 3rd and 4th lines in 3rd stanza, no rhyme in last stanza.
Some good lines, I like the idea captured.
No comma after "Hunts gone by" I think-
some clunky lines: "experiences, good and bad"-
some very good lines: "sing to my soul of ages gone by" and "Ageless you stand, tall and proud/ Lichen grows upon your surfaces"; uneven rhyme scheme does not help (1st and 4th lines in first stanza, 3rd and 4th lines in 3rd stanza, no rhyme in last stanza.
The word I think is perpetuity, not perpetuality-- if trying to coin a new word, unnecessary, annoying-
some good lines-
Very cute!
Well written, sadness staining every line...
Lovely
Cutesy. Villanelles are not easy...
Some good lines, a TON of anger...
Thanks Jill, nice to find someone here with nentwined and me after too long silence. I hope you stay awhile.
One line sticks out as not fitting the song, I think:
disliked "Yet since this rotted bad"--Liked all the rest!
well written, great imagery
lovely!
Liked it! Sadly, relate to it...
Intense. Moving.
Powerful description, strong ending.
Jill Stockinger
on Beached (Or how I learned to give up the day) by Jeremi B. Handrinos
21 Dec 2020, 6:30 PM
LOVED the line:
"The sun had just yoked"- original and excellent!
Some seemed a little lackluster: the lines"whales were sick too" and a little trite: "I saw no foot-steps home"--The first two stanzas are fresh and hardhitting. Rest of poem did not match that power.