Edna Sweetlove
on Shadows In Your Eyes by PoeticJustice
23 Sep 2006, 7:13 PM
dreary doggerel.
boring and illiterate
with out NO
without YES
illiterate.
Weird spelling and not much talent.
Drivel. Total drivel.
Dedicated April 1, 20xx
by the repentant
Carpinteria City Council
What in Christ's name does that mean?
I like this, but I think the three verses beginning with "poor artist" are overwrought. They say that an artist cannot one-up on nature, an often-said idea that's good, but can be shortened.
You know, Ranger, I always enjoy reading your poems for the language and clever phrases, but I'll be damned if I can pull many of them together and come up with some unifying picture of the poem as a whole. The meter is good here, and these are a unique ways of saying things, and maybe it's my own inadequacy as a reader, but can you come through with more clarity on the overall theme, if there is one?
Well, I can see from this how you feel, and that's a good thing. A lot of poets these days put a lid on their feelings, and all we get from them is language. What we want from you, however, is language. The other comments have said it; we want to read your clever turn of phrase and all that stuff. Just don't give up the other.
Even if it has all been said many times, the impact of it must be like that great change of address we've read so much about, but none of us can describe from experience.
agreed. this also needs something solid. too much telling about the feelings, not enough showing through actual acts and images.
instead of just telling people about the feelings, it might be helpful to try to show through concrete images how those feelings manifest themselves. right now the words are so completely vague i can't find anything to latch onto.
Ranger
replying on Beard my Homemade Negro Jesus (Improved! With AIDS!) by Everyone
23 Sep 2006, 4:16 AM
My Christ-beard caught AIDS! (from the cough
Of a Russian called Pietrokov)
So he got a disease
By the name 'Leprosy'
And the AIDS-ridden bits all fell off
It needs, well, structure. The rhythm's all over the place, which makes it difficult to read. A bit more invention with the rhymes wouldn't go amiss either - remember that rhyme is a rhythmic device and shouldn't be the primary concern. If you can't find a direct rhyme to fit the metre, rhyme loosely, no-one will be too concerned by it.
Fair enough - perhaps if I changed it to '...total disregard; those screaming slaves...'?
You rap student, you.
I like some of the imagery..."solar flowers" "a million beating fists" "screaming slaves in chain gang rows", but they just don't string together that well for me.
I like a bit more complexity.