poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 6001–6020 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

zodiac on End of day poem by ecargo 8 Sep 2006, 10:03 AM
Nice. Like richa, with rhythm.
made me laugh i'm ashamed to admit ....
ecargo on the poem reads me by daggatolar 7 Sep 2006, 5:21 PM
I like wordplay, but not sure what you're going for here.
ecargo replying on With Old Light by Ranger 7 Sep 2006, 5:07 PM
Okay--as promised, I did come back to this. And, no, no--there's enough miserable verse, in every sense, available! I'm still ambivalent about the wealth of metaphors/images--you are right that they are all pastoral, and most are really effective. I love the gentle declines of rusted gates and fraying fabrics--still usable, but inexorably fading. I also like the nostalgia of this, the not-overdone sense of regret and moving forward and fond remembrance. I want this to be more metered--it's almost iambic pentameter, but your stresses fall apart in places (and I'm not saying it has to be straight iambs, which is hard to do without sounding stilted). For example, compare this lovely stanza (pretty much straight iambic pentameter): When the rivers claim a cargo of lost jewels To ferry them o'er distant plain and crest While the trees can only watch in silent schools And shiver at the spindle wind, undressed I will try to gather up a gleaming pool Then see it slip through fingers tightly pressed With this, which seems more awkward: When the vineyards grow a grape to make a potion Of nostalgia and a sorrow for what's lost When I drink to lonely days and sad devotion And every hour is a cobweb flecked with frost On the rusted gateway of a silly notion Then our last words will disperse - with no riposte. It's sooo close. I want it to be there. Okay, my little nits aside, this is nicely done in tone and technique--you've written an olde tymey pastoral poem that doesn't sound horribly dated or terribly derivative, which is quite a feat. You've come a long way, baby. ;)
Ranger on Chronicles of a wannabe chav by Mr Pig 7 Sep 2006, 1:17 PM
Oh, mister P, once again you give us an amusing reflection on modern life. If only this could be turned into a full-length epic of beauty, barbarism and Burberry...
Ranger replying on With Old Light by Ranger 7 Sep 2006, 1:00 PM
I think, really, you're spot on. I wanted to believe that stanza 6 could work, but really knew it wouldn't - at least if I change it there'll be room for a connecting stanza. It'd also remove the temporal issue (again, you're right about and I tried to make myself think it would work). I love the idea of making the last stanza flawed...perhaps if I changed 'free of knot or tether' it might work? I couldn't say where you might have seen this before, although I wouldn't be surprised if you've found similar in Kipling or Milne (big influences :-D). I guarantee the work is my own though ;-) Once more, thank you for reading and suggesting ideas, you're always so kind about my writing :-)
Niphredil replying on Dying Abroad by zodiac 7 Sep 2006, 3:15 AM
Yes! I thought Jabberwocky as well, and even checked the original ("O frabjous day! Callooh! Callay!") but felt it slightly too silly to mention...
THIS IS MY FUCKING BEST POEM. EVER. ANYONE WHO THINKS OTHERWISE IS AN ANUS. I ONLY WANT 10/10 - ALL OTHERS GO SUCK.
I love a dental stump up my bumhole
Dovina on Flour by MacFrantic 6 Sep 2006, 2:59 PM
Yeah, I've been to those headstones, and seen that flour on her face. I've felt a mind crwoded with those thoughts. But I think the funky line ends and punctuation are attempst to shourd the impossible thing to say in poetic mystery, and it's easily seen through.
Dovina replying on From Across the Line by Dovina 6 Sep 2006, 1:55 PM
Gloriously dismal predicament.
ALChemy on Exposing Anne Frank by Caducus 6 Sep 2006, 12:10 PM
Are you Dan Brown?
ALChemy on Dying Abroad by zodiac 6 Sep 2006, 12:00 PM
"fractious day" reminds me of Jabberwocky. "Slip sibilant over the fields" doesn't really make sense but "Slip over the sibilant fields" would. The whole poem makes me think of the death scene at the end of Gladiator.
Niphredil on Dying Abroad by zodiac 6 Sep 2006, 9:36 AM
Fantastic. This goes on my fave list. I re-read it to myself just so I could hear the rhythm out loud.
Ranger on A Night By The Shore by Bhaskaryya 5 Sep 2006, 11:55 PM
Superb, another favourite :-D
Ranger on Dying Abroad by zodiac 5 Sep 2006, 11:51 PM
Unbelievably good. 'Slip sibilant...' - reference to the sound of crickets? I thought it worked well. But then again, so did the rest of the piece.
Ranger on A Year Later (edited a bit) by Sasha 5 Sep 2006, 11:40 PM
One of the best villanelles I've read on the ranker - very traditional feel to it which gets bonus points :-) I'd find an alternative for the first 'shiver' in the final stanza, and you missed the last 'to' (that's not a criticism though, just a pedantic observation ;-)) Only other whinge I have is about the exclamation marks - personally I hate them in most poetry, but you might feel they're necessary to stay in keeping with the style. That's fair enough I guess, I won't derank it on that alone. Other than that? Stunning rhythm and it flows more or less perfectly (you might want to de-capitalise the start of line 14 to retain the grammatical consistency). This just has to be added to my favourites :-)
Ranger replying on From Across the Line by Dovina 5 Sep 2006, 11:21 PM
Que?
Dovina replying on From Across the Line by Dovina 5 Sep 2006, 4:32 PM
Dismal
Dovina replying on From Across the Line by Dovina 5 Sep 2006, 4:31 PM
I had to laugh at the way you phrased that. But thanks.