poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 63821–63840 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

If more people would "jump in after themselves",they'd be a lot happier. Bravo.
INTRANSIT on Transfixed (#2) by Christof 27 Sep 2002, 4:08 AM
Since I've been on this site I've gotten better at studying others' work.This is really good. ditto.
INTRANSIT on RunOnSentence by harrytuttle 27 Sep 2002, 4:01 AM
I was going to agree with GW but then I pictured the horse and I couldn't think of anything better.A horse doesn't "jet", that would be gross. I like it as is.9
Christof replying on West Sands, late afternoon in winter by Nicholas Jones 27 Sep 2002, 3:47 AM
Yes, bonza's something I picked up from the many Australians I've worked with. It means smashing, super, great etc. I think this could be any estuary - ever been to Whitstable? Very similar effects can be achieved.
p.s. What does Bonza mean? I take it it's a good thing.
I actually wrote that poem years ago and just wrote it down from memory - it was a bit different originally, I think. I'm glad you like it. It specifically refers to the beach at St. Andrews, but I don't think you need to know that.
This is your best yet. I love the idea of barely being there, just being a space defined by the environment around you. And you end it light-heartedly. Bonza. (but a typo - 'estuary' - don't worry about it).
Nicholas Jones replying on Transfixed (#2) by Christof 27 Sep 2002, 3:38 AM
Yes, Orwell is being ironic, and it demonstrates the obsession of the character with money. It's not meant to stand as a poem in its own right, but parts of it are surprisingly good. Orwell always wanted to be a poet but was rubbish at it.
Christof replying on Transfixed (#2) by Christof 27 Sep 2002, 3:36 AM
I think I can see what you mean, some of the imagery's similar. Orwell had quite a way with a phrase, but I wonder is her being ironic?
Nicholas Jones on Transfixed (#2) by Christof 27 Sep 2002, 3:33 AM
This is the poem in question - I found it on the internet. Remember, it's written by a character in the novel. Sharply the menacing wind sweeps over The bending poplars, newly bare, And the dark ribbons of the chimneys Veer downward; flicked by whips of air, Torn posters flutter; coldly sound The boom of trains and the rattle of hooves, And the clerks who hurry to the station Look, shuddering, over the eastern rooves, Thinking, each one, ???Here comes the winter! Please God I keep my job this year!??? And bleakly, as the cold strikes through Their entrails like an icy spear, They think of rent, rates, season tickets, Insurance, coal, the skivvy???s wages, Boots, school-bills, and the next instalment Upon the two twin beds from Drage???s. For if in careless summer days In groves of Ashtaroth we whored, Repentant now, when winds blow cold, We kneel before our rightful lord; The lord of all, the money-god, Who rules us blood and hand and brain, Who gives the roof that stops the wind, And, giving, takes away again; Who spies with jealous, watchful care, Our thoughts, our dreams, our secret ways, Who picks our words and cuts our clothes, And maps the pattern of our days; Who chills our anger, curbs our hope, And buys our lives and pays with toys, Who claims as tribute broken faith, Accepted insults, muted joys; Who binds with chains the poet???s wit, The navvy???s strength, the soldier???s pride, And lays the sleek, estranging shield Between the lover and his bride.
Christof replying on Transfixed (#2) by Christof 27 Sep 2002, 3:26 AM
Thanks for that. I haven't read that - I must seek it out.
Nicholas Jones on Transfixed (#2) by Christof 27 Sep 2002, 3:20 AM
Interesting. The visual images are very strong. Lots of damage and brokenness. It makes me think of the poem that the guy writes in George Orwell's 'Keep the Aspidistra Flying' about wind and poplars.
Nicholas Jones on Transfixed (#2) by Christof 27 Sep 2002, 3:20 AM
Interesting. The visual images are very strong. Lots of damage and brokenness. It makes me think of the poem that the guy writes in George Orwell's 'Keep the Aspidistra Flying' about wind and poplars.
Nicholas Jones on Nighttime Conversation by some deleted user 27 Sep 2002, 2:51 AM
Ah, the old fruit as sexual metaphor routine. Should really have used a fig, though, rather than an apricot. Much more genital.
Christof on Cover song by bondjedi 27 Sep 2002, 2:47 AM
Don't listen to him.
Christof on Life's Unnoticables by apples_tim 27 Sep 2002, 2:45 AM
I don't understand what you mean by 'your life is for seen' - do you mean 'foreseen'?
Christof on Nighttime Conversation by some deleted user 27 Sep 2002, 2:43 AM
Is it just me or is this rude and naughty?
decadentlaurel replying on myself by decadentlaurel 26 Sep 2002, 11:33 PM
someone in grade 6 (YES EVEN FROM THE UNITED STATES. THAT NATION WHERE THE PRESIDENT IS RETARDED "PRIME MINISTER POUTINE OF CANADA WANTS TO MAKE AN IGLOO FOR US?") can punctuate and capitalize. the meaning of the poem is what is important if you dont care to read beyond that then suite yourself go read jack and jill (or whatever that kiddie book is called)
decadentlaurel replying on myself by decadentlaurel 26 Sep 2002, 11:31 PM
i dont like capitalization punctuation. ok. whatever. i dont really care too much
poetandknowit on AIDS Bonanza! by -=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. 26 Sep 2002, 8:52 PM
DA did you lose your voice. I see you creeping around. And why is this rating at 7.17 and is not on the best poem list?