poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 65361–65380 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

Christof replying on father Worked Nights by poetandknowit 12 Sep 2002, 5:51 AM
Was that my point? No, it wasn't. My point was, I can't pretend to be urban working class and a witness to domestic violence and then write about because I would be a fraud if I did. If you know about these, good for you, crack on. I'm lucky enough not to. So lay off my birds! And if you think there's some kind of special superiority inherent in your experience, then you're falling into all kinds of Romantic fallacies about the artist and suffering.
<~> replying on Anfal: Our 9/11 happened many times over by kawakurdi 12 Sep 2002, 5:50 AM
well put, mrs.g. that's it exactly.
poetandknowit replying on father Worked Nights by poetandknowit 12 Sep 2002, 5:46 AM
Actually, this poem is a bit of a joke. Anyway, merry old England does not have an urban working class and domestic violence. The ratio of wife beater does not go up after a big soccer match loss.
Katie on A Dream Awakened by impaired 12 Sep 2002, 5:21 AM
Beautiful!! I love it! One of the nicer ones i've read. 9/10
Christof on Thank You Mom by savannah 12 Sep 2002, 3:52 AM
Yep, I think this is private rather than public poetry. Your Mum will love it. Just a little grammatical point - as you've put 'For though' in one line, you don't need the 'but' in the following line.
Christof on Billie's Threnody by Frass 12 Sep 2002, 3:46 AM
I like the last few lines of this but your attempt to suggestively evoke Lady Day through your list of epithets (especially 'mahler' - I don't know this word except as the name of the composer, is that what you mean by it? Please tell!) doesn't really work for me - reductive (esp. imbiber) rather than descriptive or empathetic.
Christof on I have no Idea?...? by brazen 12 Sep 2002, 3:32 AM
I too am foozled. Super fine.
Christof on a hero jfk by dylansong 12 Sep 2002, 3:08 AM
It's good to commermorate the man, but this is a bit idealised.... what about JFK's womanizing, the Bay of Pigs, the increased involvement in Vietnam? JFK has been turned into a saint so much that we forget that he was just a man.
Christof on father Worked Nights by poetandknowit 12 Sep 2002, 1:32 AM
If I were you commenting on this poem, P&K, I would, 'oh another poem about urban American working folk. Bored again. Yawn'. It seems that we all have our favourite little subjects doesn't it? It's called experience and observation from our lives. But as I'm not you I won't draw attention to such a blindingly obvious point and then pretend that it's a crucial critical insight. Instead I shall say I like this, including the 'cat and mother'. But you need to put some birds in it...
Christof replying on Gone Away by Christof 12 Sep 2002, 1:05 AM
This is a very good point, and I shall edit forthwith. Thanks
Christof replying on Gone Away by Christof 12 Sep 2002, 1:04 AM
I think that's a bit harsh, Mr Frass, it isn't pretending to be about anything other than what it clearly states! Of course if you think it's pretentious to think about the eventual death of your loved one that may say something about you...
I think you have alot of important stories to tell. Some of these stanzas are very beautifully executed. I think if you divide these events into separate stories it would have more impact on the reader. It's too much all at once. Also, the title is inappropriate. The terrorist attacks of Sept.11th, 2001 should not be compared with the horrors other people are living. Not because it takes anything away from "9/11", but because it minimizes your own struggle. Your experiences and the experiences of the people you present to me in this poem deserve to stand on their own. I understand your point, the United States of America appears to be an arrogant self-centered nation. We'e making a big deal out of a comparatively small act of violence. But don't you see, you are contributing to the agrandizing of this event simply by putting it in the title of your poem. Our government is using this event to create a sense of nationalism and justification for war. Please do not confuse the people with their goverment. Just as in your country, the people here are nowhere near being the hypocrites their leaders are. This is not your 9/11 this is your Anfal. Explain it to us. Show us. Many of our citizens will listen, and take your words to heart. This title reduces the author from the honorable status of poet to the dishonorable status of slanderer. My wish for you is that your talent will grow, and that through your words and the words of other poets the United States will be forced listen.
I happened to like it. Pay no attention to them.
The immigrants song. how do you say; This poem is long-winded but stil manages to convey nothing, in your language? I'm giving you 3 because I like the idea of a "loser butterfly"
ifni on To You by Cha no Onna 11 Sep 2002, 11:48 PM
I rather liked stanza 4. But then I guess I'm into odd line breaks.
god'swife on 9/11 by dougsoderstrom 11 Sep 2002, 11:30 PM
I think you really oought to leave this to a poet who might have actually been there. Of course there are those professional hacks who can drum something up for the Prez. or Congress. I don't think they'd pay for this. Infact if we sent this to them they might lock you up for life as a enemy of the state and you'll never even get a chance to defend yourself as a misguided poet.
I haven't been so kind to the 9/11 tributes today. And I really pissed off Amaliea (she didn't like my Starbucks tribute haiku), among others.
<~> replying on Anfal: Our 9/11 happened many times over by kawakurdi 11 Sep 2002, 10:35 PM
why would you be banned? did you do something bad? something that, maybe you would't want santa to see? paranoia may destroyahhhh
The test was due to royalflesh deleting my comments. I thought I was banned!!
<~> replying on Anfal: Our 9/11 happened many times over by kawakurdi 11 Sep 2002, 10:31 PM
yes, you're going frass on us. but only a little. i agree with the crux of what you have said, but haven't the balls to put it out there in light of the topic. and i saw your test on the halloween poem, and wondered what that was about...scales fall away evey day, p&k.