poetandknowit
replying on Oaxaca city fragment by poetandknowit
10 Sep 2002, 8:49 AM
Thanks for the catch Christof. I want to keep it in present tense considering it is only a fragment, at least now, in a series of fragments taken from doing work south of the border (US that is). The cocks (as in fighting), many are let loose and roam the streets, and pups (everywhere) have already gone by so what they have done, sniffed and pecked, is past tense, and what the women are doing is present and future perfect (butcher) I suppose. Quite the scene though if you are ever down that way.
Fair enough old boy, point taken. But acerbic still beats acetic hands down.
acetic: of, relating to, or containing acetic acid or vinegar. Sorry, dictionary boy, but your vocabulary isn't quite the national treasure you seem to think.
ACtually it would change the cuase-and-effect of events in an intersting way - the man in the gym would no longer look out of the window becuase he heard the bird, but the lights would be triggered by the call of the bird. Yes, very interesting...
Okay then. But think about doing it my way. It works better.
The first two line sof stanza 4 are the last clause of the sentence that runs throughout stanza 3. A comma here would destroy the sentence structure. The last two lines are a sentence in their own right, verbs and everything. The decision to run over the sentence from stanza 3 was deliberate - I like to subvert my own forms sometimes.
But this is a fragment, not a sentence, and it begs a comma. S3 needs periods for consistency, if that's the flavor of the week.
This poem moves forward in sentences so I think I need the full stop. It gives a natural pause before the final sentence.
Shouldn't it be "caonoe," (not period?) Do you need the periods?
Do you mean an acerbic comment? An ascetic comment would be one that's taken a vow of celibacy, dresses in sackcloth and sleeps on a stone bed.
Your food metaphor works really well. the first stanza is impressively tight - think if you left it at that you'd have a good poem as well.
Theidea of being just a sequel is very depressing
To be fair, I don't thinkt his poem has anything to do with parents
blah balh blah blah, slightly skewed acetic comment, blah blah blah, blah blah mysterious voting system, blah blah blah blah, what d'it get, blah blah blah blah blah, the number of licks it takes to achive a shining ring. blah blah blah blah blah
Rest assured I shall be first in line with the cleaver. This is smashing.
This tells the story econmically, with a very restrained tone that really underlines the tragic events - very good.
Really good visceral stuff, but might read more easily if 'passed' became 'past' and if the women searched in the past tense with the cocks.
I quite like this, but you seem to lose grip of your rhythms towards the end - the last line just clunks a little bit. I think it needs to be shorter.
Sure ha,ha,ha that one was a joke, ha,ha,ha no honestly ha,ha,ha. Good one birthmark, had em a rolling in these isles.