poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 11181–11200 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

Nicholas Jones replying on Les Imagistes by Nicholas Jones 1 Feb 2006, 10:06 AM
I did invent the duck image; I was sitting in the freezing cold by a frozen lake during my lunch break scribbling in my notebook. The noise thiong comes from the fact it's a park just outside a town, so it is quiet in comparison but there's still the traffic noise. The point I think is that imagism is too narrow; there are many other things going on in poetry than just the images. I think a very austere imagist poem can opnly work by excluding everything else; I'd rather have excess verbosity that encompasses more than a clinical precision that excludes. I've just been reading an anthology of imagist writers, and I read the poems and think yes, that's very nice, but where's the rest?
ecargo replying on Penny Loafer Blues by ALChemy 1 Feb 2006, 7:15 AM
dingdingding! Yeah, I missed that--guess I'm a bit of an Imagist in wanting my images connected, focused, but you're right--here, the flash of unconnected images against closed lids is a sort of falling-asleep sequence, freeflowing and disordered, like dreams. Cool.
ecargo on Les Imagistes by Nicholas Jones 1 Feb 2006, 7:10 AM
Imagism is considered more of a parallel to sculpture than to painting. So the idea of "purging" or paring seems very apt--rather than layering images they focus on the core, the clean lines. This is clever because you practice what you preach--the seemingly extraneous imagery--the 7-inch, the opening stanzas. Thoughtful and thought-provoking.
ecargo on Giving in to a boring suggestion by Joe-joe 1 Feb 2006, 6:55 AM
Ha--cute. Want to take on my upstairs neighbors who walk on hard wood floors in high heels?
ecargo replying on The Book of Images by Dovina 1 Feb 2006, 6:39 AM
How well you know me, on the basis of so short an acquaintance! How perceptive! How perspicacious! If the imagery is common, why do we need a poem to point it out? We know already--it's "common." They're idiomatic for a reason--"someone thought it was a good way of communicating," and apparently we agreed. Doesn't seem like you're saying much of anything at all.
ALChemy replying on Penny Loafer Blues by ALChemy 1 Feb 2006, 6:06 AM
You should be an agent or an art dealer. You explain things better than I can. I think if you can make it work, changing the language in a poem instantly increases the attention of the reader. Thanks Ranger.
ALChemy replying on Les Imagistes by Nicholas Jones 1 Feb 2006, 5:51 AM
See I thought we were the duck and his poem was the lake. I think I understand now. It's really wabbit season.
Ranger replying on Penny Loafer Blues by ALChemy 1 Feb 2006, 5:50 AM
But surely that's the idea of the dream wife; she is not just a homey real-life icon, she is something different, something new. Just as spending a moment looking through shut eyelids can bring up images of the less-than-ordinary and the beautiful (fresh lava, stained glass etc.) The contrast of language is a mirror for this, and in the end it's the real-life language that wins.
ALChemy replying on The Book of Images by Dovina 1 Feb 2006, 5:42 AM
Mwaahaahaaha!!
Ranger replying on A Cleansing Of Creeds by Caducus 1 Feb 2006, 5:42 AM
What the monk, it says there are 3 other comments on here but I can't see them...nentwined, are you playing jokes again?
Ranger replying on Les Imagistes by Nicholas Jones 1 Feb 2006, 5:38 AM
Ah but if you take this philosophy the duck probably shot itself with the Duck-shot shell. I actually love this poem, although it did take 3 reads to get round (*taps skull to check tiny brain is still there*).
Dovina replying on The Book of Images by Dovina 1 Feb 2006, 5:37 AM
All it takes to get tens is to enumerate most of the conceivable ways to fit Jesus with a beard. And to delete comments would not be practicing what I preach. Methinks the Tempter knocketh at my door.
Ranger on A Cleansing Of Creeds by Caducus 1 Feb 2006, 5:34 AM
Stanza 4 should, ironically, become the atheists' creed.
Ranger replying on Valentine? by celticskatermatt1 1 Feb 2006, 5:31 AM
Oh, and take out the comma in line one.
Ranger on Valentine? by celticskatermatt1 1 Feb 2006, 5:30 AM
The penultimate line is far too long given how quick the rest of the poem is, line 6 is a bit cheesy, other than that a very readable ditty.
Dovina replying on The Book of Images by Dovina 1 Feb 2006, 5:13 AM
The Bible, mostly. A bunch of Bible quotes, twisted and stuck randomly together.
ALChemy on Les Imagistes by Nicholas Jones 1 Feb 2006, 5:09 AM
Your proposed method seems less like a duck on a frozen lake and more like a duck shot by a Duck-shot shell.
Caducus on The Book of Images by Dovina 1 Feb 2006, 1:48 AM
The meter might not work for some but it suits the tone of the poem. Also for me the truth in the first 4 lines of stanza 2 was spot on. Favourited ! well done.
Cool satire and how you view those who view different parts of society was done really well. Reminded me of hte Blur parklife album with its wit yet their was a sense of humor mixed in with acute observations. Is this Dark Angel inspired? or are you not one of his many aka's?
It is everything that was in my head at one moment, at one time. Flames of thought, burning bright, junping torch to torch in death, lighting dark recesses, buried beneath a coat of dust, being swept away, to be poured down the drain, as you question, these strange breath's that I call an answer, are merely images captured by a floating attention span, traslated to text in my passing with a computer screen. <3 Jason