poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 11721–11740 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

ALChemy replying on What is it about brothers? by Tara57 19 Jan 2006, 2:51 PM
Careful now, you'll scare her away for another year.
ecargo on What is it about brothers? by Tara57 19 Jan 2006, 2:45 PM
Disagree that this is overwrought (well, some lines are, but for the most part I don't think it is)--the words are simple and the emotion strongly conveyed. Some problems with the ending--it starts to fall apart with all the fathersistermotherlovers and the repetition of "listen to me now," but the bulk of it is pretty well done. The Cain and Abel ref is a little too obvious (for my taste)--think it'd be better implied. The concrete homey details--sharing baths, etc., give the larger themes a face, which works nicely. Some editing would make it even better.
zodiac replying on What is it about brothers? by Tara57 19 Jan 2006, 2:39 PM
I think it's the most poignant thing I've written lately.
ecargo replying on What is it about brothers? by Tara57 19 Jan 2006, 2:38 PM
How Salingeresque. (JD, not Pierre. But you knew that.)
Dovina replying on Racism 4 by Dovina 19 Jan 2006, 2:34 PM
I agree that it’s better not to tell everyone what a poem is about with a title like Racism (and more scholarly too). It’s better to let them figure it out from the story. I did it this way on Poemranker to draw the series together and to build on No. 1. Your point is well taken.
ecargo replying on Spinning, reeling by ecargo 19 Jan 2006, 2:32 PM
Hee--that obvious, huh? I'd cut the hair, but, dammit, it's my truest claim to beauty. ;)
ecargo replying on Spinning, reeling by ecargo 19 Jan 2006, 2:30 PM
Well, as my first commenter put it: " don't care at all about what you have to say . . .". Therein lies the problem. It was much more immediate when I first posted it back in '03 or whatever. Now we're all just tired. (I know I am.) But I did rewrite the ending and all, and I did tell myself that for every new one I wrote I could repost an old one so . . . there you go.
richa replying on Racism 4 by Dovina 19 Jan 2006, 2:27 PM
OMG your real name is sharon.
zodiac on What is it about brothers? by Tara57 19 Jan 2006, 2:26 PM
After my little sister attempted suicide, a counselor told her it was all my brothers' and my fault. Now she lives with my mom and collects Middle America postcards with nothing written on them. I can't tell her anything, so I just send postcards.
zodiac on Heirophant by cyan9 19 Jan 2006, 2:24 PM
Femininity. Three 'i's. Otherwise, not bad.
richa replying on Racism 4 by Dovina 19 Jan 2006, 2:24 PM
It would be more scholarly to write a poem with a place and a voice and the theme of racism in it. That way your poem would not be wrong. It would be a poem in which something happened and the reader could examine its significance. There is far too much telling in your poems. Of this series I like the first one best but the end spoils it by saying what the black people are thinking.
zodiac on Three Skinheads by Caducus 19 Jan 2006, 2:24 PM
If I were, say, High Emperor of Poetry, I'd make a law forbidding the use of 'as' for linking clauses.
zodiac on Spinning, reeling by ecargo 19 Jan 2006, 2:22 PM
The people who care don't need more convincing.
zodiac on Spinning, reeling by ecargo 19 Jan 2006, 2:21 PM
The people who needed to know this already think you're nuts, on account of your hair and hanging around all day on a pastel-blue poetry site.
Dovina replying on Racism 4 by Dovina 19 Jan 2006, 2:20 PM
Did you see my homepage explanation for Dovina?
zodiac on Is Dying Ugly? by D. $ Fontera 19 Jan 2006, 2:19 PM
If you're drunk and horny, dying looks alright, I guess.
zodiac on Pain, I Curse Thee by woodstock20000 19 Jan 2006, 2:15 PM
I just saw Pain and, man, he's shaking in his boots.
zodiac on The Deep End by drnick 19 Jan 2006, 2:15 PM
It's generally not a good idea to give your poem the same name as a movie, good or bad, similar or not. Also, loose should be lose.
ALChemy replying on Racism 4 by Dovina 19 Jan 2006, 2:14 PM
I didn't say you needed it. If you call yourself Dovina you have to be either beautiful or a transvestite.
zodiac on Racism 4 by Dovina 19 Jan 2006, 2:12 PM
For bad grammar and generally taking silly things for granted - 5, sadly.