Prince of Void
replying on Do 20 always make this poem sense? by Prince of Void
15 Jan 2006, 11:15 PM
can u tell me what's the right grammar ,?
I like this better than the others--a little more oblique but more effective for it. "Two became one flesh" is a cliche; might want to recast in more original words. Maybe start off with a stronger word than "It"--what hit like an asteroid? Stands in for the real word, which is always less direct and, thus, effective.
When you use a twist on a cliche in your title, I expect to find some allusion to the cliche in the poem. I like the third verse.
This is good,but I think present tense would be better than dodging, drinking, ratioining, etc.
To answer your title question, no. It would help to get the grammar right; but even then, I don't see that it makes sense.
Thanks.
For those who have not followed this exciting series:
Racism: http://poemranker.com/poem-details.jsp?i d=124271
Racism 2: http://poemranker.com/poem-details.jsp?i d=136882
this is really good, i read this first then pt2&1 and prefer this. the opening is powerful and makes you want to read on while this powerful message is drawn to the end in same way. very blunt language used to good effect. well done
If it says what I think it might, it's a nice picture. Could you make it more clear, and say stand instead of stands?
Nicholas Jones
replying on Uncontrolled scribblings one luch break by Nicholas Jones
15 Jan 2006, 12:38 PM
Have to disappoint but I actually 'borrowed' the iron January image.....
i like this piece alot. very accurate descriptions and quite animated. i would love to see you write a piece from a different angle e.g how wonderful winter can be. well done
this seems to be a very angry piece atlest that is the way i read it but i cant seem to find reasons within the anger that justify it?
How did you know that he wouldn't know who Roger Daltrey was? Which, by the way he corrected your spelling on.
"Though I know that the hypnotized never lie" -Roger Daltrey from the song "We won't get fooled again".
Is that the one with Wayne Brady?
"This racist stuff is killing me inside" -Dave Chappelle from the skit "The Niggar Family".
http://www.limanon.com/menu/films/chapel le/niggarfamily.html
i thought this was super, great use of descriptive language where you can almost here the children playing and chattering. well done
The main problem with this is too much telling, not enough showing. Dave Chappelle does a bit about being driven into the projects and knowing that's where they were headed because: "gun store, gun store, liquor store, gun store." That raises an immediate image, just those few words. That's what's missing here. More "liquor store,
the greasy hot-dog stand" and less narrative and blatant point-making.