poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 11861–11880 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

This poem does not make sense.
zodiac on They Knew Me From Adam by D. $ Fontera 17 Jan 2006, 10:17 AM
Lose some of the throwaway phrases and commentary - "But, of course, it is harder than you can imagine," "over, yet again," the last bit. Otherwise, nice.
zodiac on Reap by ecargo 17 Jan 2006, 10:14 AM
This is really great, biteme. My only suggestion: wreathe should be wreath.
Good work, Amanda. I especially like the first and seventh verses (though "did be" should just be "were"). Nice.
ecargo replying on Reap by ecargo 16 Jan 2006, 5:32 PM
More mood than meaning.
ecargo replying on Green things by ecargo 16 Jan 2006, 5:23 PM
<waggles my fingers to z> Actually--a typo. It should be "we break like ice." You'd think I'd proof my own stuff, huh? ;-)
ecargo replying on Green things by ecargo 16 Jan 2006, 5:21 PM
Actually, I reverted to an earlier version. Hardly a major revision, by the way. This has been kicking around in one form or another for ages, and I've never gotten it to a point that I liked. Probably past time to lay it to rest.
richa on A Haiku by amanda_dcosta 16 Jan 2006, 3:18 PM
This is a meta-ku if anything.
richa on Racism 2 by Dovina 16 Jan 2006, 3:14 PM
I gather this poem is about a white person who goes to a black inner-city and buys a greasy hot dog and liquor store stuff and is treated well by the black people. The black people would like when they visit the middle-class white person's town to be treated the same way but they are not. It is just not a very realistic scenario.
amanda_dcosta on Reckoning by <~> 16 Jan 2006, 9:54 AM
Good work! Keep it up.
amanda_dcosta on A SURREAL DEPREDATION! by anushree 16 Jan 2006, 9:42 AM
Sorry, but I am unable to connect with this poem. Phrases are good, but somehow it doesn't balance on the whole.
amanda_dcosta on THE NIGHT STAGE by anushree 16 Jan 2006, 9:36 AM
Not quite specific and structured as your previous piece. Somehow the punch is missing.
<~> on Green things by ecargo 16 Jan 2006, 9:35 AM
"none to straddle worlds or shoulder skies." is a great line. "We break us like ice;" is unclear; what do you mean by this?
amanda_dcosta on A LOVER’S TORMENT by anushree 16 Jan 2006, 9:32 AM
Very beautifully worded. may be a bit forced, but on the whole you could justify your choice of words. Your presentation of the theme is what stands out. Good work.
Alchemy, thanks a ton. Somehow, each time I think about her I feel I could go on writing and writing about her. She is the inspiration behind my dream as a poet, and probably someday she would probably smile her full smile when she sees my book published.
Dovina on Green things by ecargo 16 Jan 2006, 6:24 AM
I'd rather you did not delete the comments when you make a revision. If you make a major revision, like this one, it seems better to post it as a new poem. Better than the first.
Dovina on Reap by ecargo 16 Jan 2006, 6:10 AM
I see a rural harvest time in a hollow, but miss the point, if it's more than that.
You have validated her work in my opinion.
This is a poem I wrote last year (21st Jan), while on the train, on my way to my Grandma's funeral. Her name is Pearl Heldt, and she was such a wonderful person to me and my family, and it was with deep sorrow and gratitude that I wrote this. You might find a lot of portions need editing, but I have kept it this way, unedited, due to the fact that I wrote it spontaneously, within 15 - 20 min. for her. All the same, critiques view is welcome. We will be celebrating her 1st death anniversary on the 20th Jan. May her soul rest in peace.
zodiac replying on Do 20 always make this poem sense? by Prince of Void 15 Jan 2006, 11:53 PM
Can you tell us what a line like "Do 20 always make this poem sense" means?