ALChemy
replying on How Angels Smell by Dovina
28 Sep 2005, 7:23 AM
As it turns out I can not really hear you for I am only a figment of your imagination.
Too many words. "charred room that had once been ablaze" for example, could be just "charred room."
Good, and moves to a goal. The last few lines wrap it up nicely.
Speculation and joining of speculated ideas is what poetry is and what you've done here. Just leave off the opening remark.
Hear the Gospel According to Dovina! How dare you question it?
Haunting once you become engaged the piece
The clarity with which you recount emotional reasoning is very good here, ther are however lines like:
Nor a faint sense of grime
That break from the rhythm and flow of the piece without having any apparent purpose in being there (am I missing something? what is a faint sense of grime?). The other problem that I have is that there are several changes in the structure of the piece, that break the flow with a new structure each time you move from verse to verse. This can be quite effective when you want the reader to pause for thought or you want to provide a contrast, but here I think a more flowing structure would assist.
Analogy is well used here, the second verse feels a bit long for my likings, some kind of break or use of a bit more varied language might have pulled me in a bit more in that verse, rather than just being compelled to glance it over.
You wouldn't lose the commentary, only the votes. The other misspelling is 'knash' for 'gnash'.
chorde is cord and there is another spelling mistake in here somewhere, but i dont wont to lose the commentry by changing it. If whispers of me to enter makes no sense to you, then perhaps a browse through some slightly less modern work may assist, in any case the gate is tempting me through in this instance.
The answer to your question, of course.
I'm presuming 'chorde' is 'cord'? And 'that whispers of me to enter' -- should that me 'whispers to me' or was the gate whispering about it, in which case 'to enter' makes no sense.
Very well written, though.
Was he in shining armour at the ball? Must be a pretty tough guy to dance the Volta with sixty kilos of metal on him...
Gratuitously emetic
Gentle, moody and contemplatative (a very nice combination) - there is sufficient thought within the first paragraphs to force me to ask where I can read more of your work (a rarity). I would say I lost the thread a bit in the middle verse though, but was so enchanted by the end of the second verse that I quickly glanced over that.
Nice write, intricate.
The Villanelle's much better.