Comments byzodiac, 741–760 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

on Silent Night by Dovina 29 Nov 2005, 3:00 AM
A ream look at a fast pull, and no slang. You could have done this a lot faster by simply adding the word "not" to the beginning of each line. And it would have been just as clever.
replying on Picking Up Sins by BrandonW 29 Nov 2005, 2:33 AM
Out of curiosity, what term do you use most often in normal conversation? In writing?
replying on Games by BrandonW 29 Nov 2005, 2:31 AM
I've been reading a poetry anthology edited by Billy Collins where he (Billy) capitalizes the first words of lines I know weren't capitalized in their originals. It is a little off-putting. Seems like most poets I read do capitalize occasional poems, but nowhere near consistently. I think it's mainly a problem for people who aren't used to reading through enjambment.
replying on A Modern Woman by Dovina 29 Nov 2005, 2:20 AM
This sucks. You can't hold a metaphor straight for an entire line, but I'm getting called on inconsistent disses?
replying on Indian Song by ALChemy 29 Nov 2005, 2:17 AM
I got "God turned his head," but yours is better. Also, leave "sin" on the end of line 3.

AlChemy: If he's right on line 4, change it. The second stanza is perfect, both translated and not.
replying on The mountain has come to Mohammed by ALChemy 29 Nov 2005, 2:13 AM
I warn you, it may star Jeff Bridges. In which case it won't make any money anyway, and everyone should just pirate it.
replying on The mountain has come to Mohammed by ALChemy 29 Nov 2005, 2:12 AM
I do know the show and remember the song, which plays over a scene where the hero levitates using aerosol cans, among other things.
replying on A Modern Woman by Dovina 29 Nov 2005, 2:10 AM
Who's sensitive? All the Western women I know are well-adjusted and untroubled about things like whether they should be more or less feminine in the workplace. None of them think that, as far as the West goes, either sex dominates things; nor would they be able to say what either sex would dominate if it did. It's nice. We drink a lot and play Scategories. You're the ones who seem conflicted about things.
replying on The mountain has come to Mohammed by ALChemy 28 Nov 2005, 6:35 AM
I'm going to call myself Sofia Coppola and the movie Lost in Translation with scary foreigners instead of cute Japanese ones and nobody as lovely as Scarlett Johanssen. God knows it'll flop for exactly that reason.

Disqualified. I'm tired of anything heroic being a metaphor for Jesus. Heroic things seem to be metaphors for Jesus because Jesus himself is a metaphor for heroic things.
replying on Indian Song by ALChemy 28 Nov 2005, 6:24 AM
After we've given everyone a chance, I'll post my interpretation and see how far off it is. I've definitely got line 5, but now I'm worried about 6, which for me involved the unlikely word "resurrect".
on Indian Song by ALChemy 28 Nov 2005, 4:10 AM
Clever. I'm not sure I got lines 4 and 5, but what I think I got I like.
replying on A Modern Woman by Dovina 28 Nov 2005, 4:07 AM
Truly. But all this 'men don't understand women, women don't understand men, men are pigs, women are pigs' stuff is completely alien to me now. I guess there's nothing like living in a misogynist Muslim country to make people figure out their priorities.
replying on The mountain has come to Mohammed by ALChemy 28 Nov 2005, 4:04 AM
Having just submitted a poem comparing Islamic terrorists to annoying mosquitoes, I'm in no position to talk.
replying on The mountain has come to Mohammed by ALChemy 28 Nov 2005, 4:03 AM
The older I get, the more I realise how influenced I am by the whole O'Henry/sci-fi ironic twist. When I want to be literary, I tell myself it's O'Henry; when I'm realistic I tell myself it's sci-fi. You know he's buried in Asheville, NC, where I've spent a lot of the last eight years. The Islam movie is going to be pure visually-stunning plotless ensemble drama. Maybe unfortunately.

"I promised that from now on I would write only for the Lord... [Jesus is] the ultimate supernatural hero, the ultimate immortal of them all."
- Anne Rice, October 2005
on listen by elderking 27 Nov 2005, 6:07 AM
The last line's good; the first 8 don't make words do anything they haven't done for six hundred years at least.
on The Mask by TLRufener 27 Nov 2005, 6:06 AM
Yeah, you have to wonder if you're really going to be able to convey your feelings and experiences and make an accurate account of your life and times if you can only write 13-syllable sentences...
replying on The mountain has come to Mohammed by ALChemy 27 Nov 2005, 6:00 AM
It's not just that it's too focused; it's something like making a poem almost entirely out of images of a character named Sexy Sadie breaking the rules and making fools of everyone. Saying that the worm is only bringer of death (where Poe's is death/some grand lord-or-mascot of death) isn't enough. At least my Conqueror Worm is a mezcal worm and not anything to do very literally with death. And besides, I wrote it drunk, that's got to count for something. Yes, I can't think of a better image for Bush at the moment - but that is our job, isn't it? To come up with new hard-to-think-of images that seem so obvious and perfect to future generations looking to rip off easy images?

No, it's neither too vague nor too obvious.
replying on A Modern Woman by Dovina 27 Nov 2005, 5:58 AM
It's funny how no part of this conversation has any connection to my life or any woman I know. No, wait, that's not funny...
replying on The mountain has come to Mohammed by ALChemy 27 Nov 2005, 5:54 AM
I think that's because he's mainly discussing the conflict between the West and bin Laden's brand of jihadism, and not Islam in general.

PS AlChemy: I really dug the rhyme and half-rhyme this time, and the way your rock references reflect the rock referencing of a million Vietnam War movies.
replying on One Second by TLRufener 27 Nov 2005, 5:44 AM
I often agree with you, or at least grant you certain points, while you never agree with me. I'm sure by your logic this means you're winning.