poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 45921–45940 back. Include replies to comments

Caducus on some deleted poem 3 Dec 2002, 1:49 AM
Boobalicious!
Very good, in fact its bad (in true gansta style).
ecargo on The Magician by Hooman 2 Dec 2002, 5:07 PM
I think you mean "fear is a desert," not a crepe suzette. I don't mock--I once wrote "draught holds the memory of water." (Which it surely does, but that wasn't the point.)
ecargo on some deleted poem 2 Dec 2002, 5:16 PM
I'd like this if only because you used "crenellated" without using "battlements"--but I like it for a lot of other reasons. Lovely sustained imagery. Stanza three--think it'd be stronger if you ended on "threaded [with?] the colors of the morn" and dropped the next line.
-=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. on The Magician by Hooman 2 Dec 2002, 5:20 PM
Those who abhor slavery, are themselves slaves to their own ignorance. Lev 15:6
Tintagiles on hate by ts 2 Dec 2002, 7:15 PM
Dear God. Please, please, PLEASE tell me the spelling mistakes were on purpose. PLEASE.
Bachus on The Magician by Hooman 2 Dec 2002, 11:27 PM
anyone that can sit and find an opinion on that many differentiating labels deserves atleast an 8. whether i agree with what was contrasted or not.
Caducus on Pretty Skin Deep by confuzdlilgirl 3 Dec 2002, 1:18 AM
When I was your age I wrote in a similar style to you. I put the emphasis on rhyme rather than substance or style, your writing will mature and you wont recognize how your styles changed till 1 day you'll look over what you've written and say unto yourself 'Did I write this'?, the best advice is dont chuck anything away you may use two choice lines in a better poem, Rebecca Calvetti gave you a constructive piece of criticism, and you can still keep your individuality yet take advice on board - some good lines/bad lines here, just keep trying -5-
cleverdevice on some deleted poem 3 Dec 2002, 1:31 AM
Excellent, it reminds me of...I won't go into it, too many supressed memories. ('Fat festish cleverdevice!')
I love the irony at the end of this it had me panting like Lassie being boned by beethoven, what i like even more though is the fact that the 'phantom' 1 voter has yet to serve up their cowardly custard and say to everyone 'I'm desperate to be loved but y'all hate my poems so I'm gonna hate yours, heres a deserved 9 to balance the books.
whats cleo's number horus?
Caducus on Embarrassed by Goose 3 Dec 2002, 2:00 AM
The goose has layed a golden egg ! Well done indeed BUT......... check line 6, its cower you want now cow, or it sounds like line dancing for cows.
Caducus on My One True Love by Hooman 3 Dec 2002, 2:02 AM
A bit too syrupy for me, but for your romantic self kiss a 6
Caducus on some deleted poem 3 Dec 2002, 2:04 AM
A poets name, a poets poem what more can i add ===========9=====
Caducus on Silence by Cha no Onna 3 Dec 2002, 2:08 AM
Intelligent idea here which you've dealt with well, I liked the way you sold fragility here and the end stanza and last line hit the throat - nice one *8* (try and shorten the line about the wet earth it affects the readability)
Caducus on TRIBUTE TO A FRIEND by Nicholas Monson 3 Dec 2002, 4:37 AM
Haven't read an ode on here for ages, this aint bad really heres a 7
<~> on Silence by Cha no Onna 3 Dec 2002, 8:29 AM
this is beautiful. but, in the third stanza, you say we sing, then in the single line (s4?) you say that you are mute. you keep crossing the line/confusing solitary (i, them) and together (we). if you worked this out, this would be near perfect. nice job.
<~> on some deleted poem 3 Dec 2002, 8:32 AM
you,ve remebered an awful lot for someone who has forgotten. nice job.
I think I was there, I grabbed your cock, rememver, that tall muscular 'girl'!
Beaner99 on Dust by Caducus 2 Dec 2002, 6:07 PM
wonderful...9