poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 27761–27780 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

I don't know why anyone would give this poem anything below a ten. Very good.
Brittanyy on AIDS in a van by -=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. 4 Jul 2004, 6:04 PM
I dont know who in their right mind would even consider giving THIS poem a 10..It's pure garbage..Thats all I can say..You Suck and Your Poem Sucks.. -0-
Brittanyy on The Nude by -=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. 4 Jul 2004, 6:00 PM
Hmm well..This poem is so bad it makes me feel better about my poems and for that I will grant you a...-5-
Brittanyy on Oh No! by foothangingoutofass 4 Jul 2004, 5:55 PM
Ok this poem was just a bad attempt to be funny and well...It's not..Nice try champ better luck next time..
?-Dave_Mysterious-? on Recycled Stardust by Quarton 4 Jul 2004, 2:49 PM
Hello. Perhaps I can shed some light on this matter. I have a degree in science from Strathclyde Univesity, and I can confirm that: a) This poem is wrong b) Science is true.
?-Dave_Mysterious-? on Your sad goodbye by sanity 4 Jul 2004, 2:38 PM
I like the way you use clouds as a metaphor for the human condition.
?-Dave_Mysterious-? on Tapestry Years by Quarton 4 Jul 2004, 2:36 PM
A think of life as being more of a sort of crochet.
?-Dave_Mysterious-? on Fancy by reanna 4 Jul 2004, 2:34 PM
This poem is utterly unintelligible - the unmistakable hallmark of excellent poetry!!!!1
?-Dave_Mysterious-? on Translation by Dovina 4 Jul 2004, 2:28 PM
You seem to be suggesting there is some merit in an idea that can only be adequately articulated in one language. What buncombe. A meaningful statement can be expressed in any comprehensive language, such as English, and any information lost in the translation can only be meaningless, emotive hogwash.
zodiac replying on Recycled Stardust by Quarton 4 Jul 2004, 11:54 AM
Your spelling of 'self-righteous' is bogus and self-righteous. And you clearly haven't bothered very much reading my 'arguments' or you would have seen that I was speaking purely scientifically and no offense intended. What I meant was, do you believe the notion we call 'gravity' is something personal and variable (eg, you might not, in fact, fall when you walk off a cliff), or is it part of a useful model for the universe which may be applied pretty consistently to almost all imaginable situations (eg, you probably will fall, like most things do)?
Quarton on Translation by Dovina 4 Jul 2004, 11:44 AM
This is really quite a lovely little poem. I love the last three stanzas and my only suggestion is the third stanza. IMO, it doesn't quite flow as well as the rest of the poem. Still, it's exceptional as is. Good stuff and a solid nine.
Quarton replying on Time's End by Quarton 4 Jul 2004, 11:13 AM
Dovina... Thanks for the read and taking the time to comment and your suggestions. Brevity is definitely a goal to strive for in writing poetry and I agree with you. Actually, I often suggest this when commenting on other poems and guess I should take my own advice. Your version reads quite well and your critique is appreciated.
Dan garcia-Black on When by Cairsten 4 Jul 2004, 10:27 AM
I would have given up to two teeth I have left to have written such a poem. Anyone want to trade two teeth for a blender?
Dovina on Tapestry Years by Quarton 4 Jul 2004, 10:00 AM
What a great future! I think even the footprints in time blow away. A tapestry carefully woven and inevitibly unraveled. Please see my comment on Time's End.
Quarton replying on Recycled Stardust by Quarton 4 Jul 2004, 9:57 AM
Sorry. I should have put my comments under Zodiac's post, not yours.
SupremeDreamer replying on Recycled Stardust by Quarton 4 Jul 2004, 9:26 AM
What the hell is wrong with you? I'm not zodiac. I'm SupremeDreamer, also known as DreamerSupreme, Don-Quixote, Y2kSlamPoet, and Shit-Crumpets. I am wholly different and seperate from zodiac, so please don't mistake me for him. :P
You're right, sorry.
In all honesty, I must ask: wheres the fire, and why do I feel so limp? Take my five and be gone!
Heh, yeah, it's a bit more fluid without "then".. the things a poet will notice in time, tsk, it's amazing the things I've written in the past and the little hiccups I find in them now or not too far off into the future.. I've deducted it from my pc copy. I'm happy you enjoyed the piece, and appreciate you vote and feedback.
He didn't, he gave me an eight for the first version months ago. You'll notice that beneath the voting graph there is a link called "view voting details", click it and you'll see that sanity was the one who gave me a one. Just wanted to clear that up so no one gets blamed for someone elses vote heh.