amanda_dcosta
on Sonnet 5 (The Second Deluge) by Schlinkey
3 Dec 2006, 2:08 AM
I admire anyone who can write a beautiful sonnet, for this is something I have not achieved yet. You have done a swell job at it and hence I choose not to be too critical about its contents.
Hmmm.. I think this could be shortened to contain less detail and more impact.
I kinda wonder how you come up with the contents you write. Pretty good , I must say.
Ranger... this is just too good. I read it a couple of times..but never got down to commenting. Sorry for the delay. Keep writing. You do a very good job at it.
Thanks! I'm not all that proficient with the use of punctuation in my poems.
I've understood as much :) That you don't really like the form that is. I find it refreshing writing sonnets though, so I'll keep at it! (for a time at least). As to perfect innocence. I'm not sure, but innocence in itself is a term loosely used. Perfect innocence though, that would like the epitome of the very concept. Then again, when I decide to write stuff like this, it will come out kinda, well, "ugh" for some. :D
Thanks, as always, for your thoughts. It's neat when someone disagrees with you!
You need an extra exclamation mark in line 5.
I don't see anything wrong with the 'deluge' line, nothing unforgivable at least. Line two needs some punctuation ('The nascent truth - a herald's cries of war' would do it).
You have the pentameter consistent this time. And it has the feel of old-time sonnets. But, again I find it constrained to the meter, and this time to the loss of meaning. For example, "perfect" adds little to "innocece" besides pentameter and overstatement. And "Deluge" has the accent on "uge." I could do no better with it, however, and think the best solution might be to give up on pentameter or on sonnet. Sorry, I have little respect for the form, and that's part of the problem.
True that. I switched on purpose though. Felt that tetrameter would do perfectly in the couplet :)
I don't really agree with scornful and grim being that similar. But I do, however, agree with you saying I've used some words to make the pentameter work. If I wanted to write modern stuff, I'd stick to wishy washy free verse, just jamming with words. Seeing as I'm not really skilled doing that, I'll keep fiddling with these older forms. That's the thing with writing in strict forms, it's not easy making it all slippery easy greasy to read. All over, I'm content though. If you have any suggestions as to make it better, I'll be happy to hear em :)
Sonnets don't have to be pentameter, not in modern circles anyway. But when you start that way and switch to four iambs in the last two lines, it sounds like a switch of gears. Also, in Line 3, scornful and grim are so similar that it sounds like one of them was added for pentameter's sake.
Yopu either need to masturbate into a woman or get trapped in one, either way this is utter village .
What utter nonsense, if you didn't own this site you would not get half the tens you get. That is utter bum sweat.
This has some good imagery, but the punctuation was lazy and it sounds like it should be shorter.
Boredome and Ignorance. Alas I'm held captive.