poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 4761–4780 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

"The Loom the Witch and the Wardrobe" wasn't as spiritually fulfiling as the David Attenborough documentary "Planet Loom".
Dovina on Wretch by MacFrantic 28 Nov 2006, 8:47 PM
Pretty neat, making all the lines of the same number of characters. And it has a good point to boot. Nice.
Are you trying to hit on Darkie now? My god woman, have you no DECENCY?? ;P
Dovina replying on Journey To The Centre Of The Loom by -=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. 28 Nov 2006, 9:32 AM
What the loom needs now is love, sweet love.
Dovina replying on Sonnet 3 (Farewell my muse) by Schlinkey 28 Nov 2006, 9:31 AM
I prefer it as one syllable. It rings better that way, no?
Twenty Thousand Looms Under the Sea
Schlinkey replying on Sonnet 3 (Farewell my muse) by Schlinkey 27 Nov 2006, 8:00 PM
Quarrel, two syllables (QUARrel), no?
Dovina replying on Sonnet 3 (Farewell my muse) by Schlinkey 27 Nov 2006, 7:48 PM
And AS this QUARREL now ENDS, my TEARS shall RUN
Schlinkey replying on Sonnet 3 (Farewell my muse) by Schlinkey 27 Nov 2006, 3:06 PM
Agree on the "do"s as well. Adding the "now" in line 13 would mess up the pentameter though. Thanks! :)
Dovina on Sonnet 3 (Farewell my muse) by Schlinkey 27 Nov 2006, 2:50 PM
I agree with Ranger on the "do"s. I think you could make both of them "shall". The rhythm is good in all but Line 13. Try "And as this quarrel now ends, my tears shall run."
Schlinkey replying on Sonnet 3 (Farewell my muse) by Schlinkey 27 Nov 2006, 2:28 PM
Haha! I've been fixing that as you wrote your comment. Thanks a lot for for putting that to my attention. Haven't really taken time to work out the punctuation in these sonnets. Hope it's a bit better now?
Ranger on Sonnet 3 (Farewell my muse) by Schlinkey 27 Nov 2006, 2:26 PM
I'd cut a few of the commas and replace them with alternative punctuation - purely for presentation. Other than that I enjoyed this, although I rarely like seeing the dummy auxiliary 'do' used, even in a classical style. If it's possible to edit that out, it might be worthwhile.
Ranger on Raising the nap by howl 27 Nov 2006, 2:23 PM
'Slow as the creep of soil' is a really nice image. Does 'teas' want an apostrophe?
Ranger replying on Sonnet 2 (Eulogy for a clerk) by Schlinkey 27 Nov 2006, 2:18 PM
There's nothing wrong with internal rhymes - same as with end-rhymes - so long as they're consistent. I wouldn't worry about the English pronunciation; most English have forgotten it too.
I eagerly await 'Around the Loom in Eighty Days'
Schlinkey replying on Sonnet 2 (Eulogy for a clerk) by Schlinkey 27 Nov 2006, 2:10 PM
Thank you for these points! I'll have to ponder hard on these internal rhymes which seem to be a problem in most my sonnets. To be honest, I'd completely forgotten the other way to pronounce "clerk". Darnit!
Ranger on Sonnet 2 (Eulogy for a clerk) by Schlinkey 27 Nov 2006, 1:57 PM
Another very readable sonnet, although again I'm unconvinced by the initial internal rhyming - it sets up an expectation that isn't carried through. It needs punctuation after each quote in order to satisfy the grammar nazi, and over here 'clerk' is pronounced 'clark' which screws up your final rhyme, but that's not really an issue. 'Almond eyes' is really good, conjures up cyanide connotations (works well with the death), and the last two lines are well worked.
it's good ..and keep going on this way ..don't trun it into other ways
Don't trample my dreams ;(
howl on Sonnet 2 (Eulogy for a clerk) by Schlinkey 27 Nov 2006, 2:12 AM
Like the curate's egg. I don't like 'Your scornful view on things is far too grim;'.