Dovina
on Wry Edward's wry smile by oddgreenout
15 Oct 2006, 2:05 PM
Limericks usually march along with sing-song rhythm in addition to the rhyming scheme. What is a hawlk? A few too many commas, it seems, and a meaning covered in unusual language.
Thanks for reading it thrice. What I said was more like âMore hands = more chickens = more revenue.â The problem is that our present six-billion population is destined for nine billion by 2050 if we donât scrap that idea. And women all over the world are mostly willing to scrap it, if only their ruling men would agree.
The concept of finality is a transient one, unless weâre talking about death. Everything else seems to me non-final. We can say that something has ended â a marriage, a job, college, parenthood, an amputated limb â but it has a way of resurrecting, like her decision never to read poetry again.
I had to laugh at your suggestion on âmarvel and laugh,â not because it isnât metrically better, it is, but because you hold such a high regard for meter. You are a poet, while I am a mere philosopher.
The âextreme resultâ is her decision based on feelings of bitterness and hurt. Itâs meant to show that in such an emotional state, our thinking loses objectivity and clarity. It mires in our perceived dilemma.
Yes, but it's populated mostly by non-whites with a religion which nobody understands, odd-shaped gods, brightly-coloured clothes, stuff being sold in the street, and lepers. So of course it's going to be seen as full of quaintly backward poor people too helpless to do anything for theirselves by those of us fortunate enough to live in this respectably black-suited world of legalities and pristine healthcare. I mean, it's not as though we have to worry about beggars here, is it?
OK then more precise verbs.
Computer generated? Is that possible?
Sea-jade firstling's ribbon curl
Snaking slowly from the womb
Time to see a seasonal lunar shape, right? Any other poets wanting to join in this little project, feel free (check the link above to get the pattern).
Yeah, the poem would be much better if it had 'zinzulated', 'expounded' and 'anaesthetised'.
it means rhymes that primary school children use.
The same content would make a decent poem if your verbs weren't so dull.
Jesus rocks.
Startled embryo
Stepped-on, mucked-up, matted,
packed in sod
(that was verse 11; almost 1/3 done)
the whole event seems a bit dry and distant. as a reader i can relate, but still have trouble caring about the characters. maybe try using some present tense to add immediacy? I disagree with nick about "aware of her insignificance." Although the line tells about feelings that are meaningful, they could be better shown through body language or imagery. the last line is too much information unsupported; what comes before does not adequately suggest a reason for such an extreme result.
Mr. Tanner is a Harry Chapin song. The story behind it is of a man who loves singing, is persuaded to do a show, gets shot down by the critics and never sings again. This is where the need for some sort of conclusiveness comes in - the fact that she never read after this is pretty final, isn't it? I mean, you say in your comment that she *could* read again someday, but the poem contradicts that.
Also, the way this is set up seems to show every line as being a definite action in a series of events. The weak endings let each line sort of run into the next, but I don't think it needs that. It feels to me like each line wants to be solid, conclusive. So for instance, you could write 'tried to make him marvel, laugh'. Or even 'marvel and laugh' if you're not too worried about iambic metre. This way I find lines end for good and the reader can then move on to the next event.