poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 5381–5400 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

I read it as more a war poem than simply a dying breath one. The second line in the last stanza is offbeat but the rest is rather brilliant.
Ranger replying on "Twee" by Ranger 5 Oct 2006, 3:36 PM
Hurdle
nentwined replying on Peter by Wakeboarder20 5 Oct 2006, 10:27 AM
I don't know the story you're referencing in enough detail to really know what's going on from the poem. It makes more sense on a line level, now, so it's not until I get to the end that I really know I don't know what's going on. I'd change "claiming he is" to "claiming to be"--things are vague enough that there could be _another_ he... or perhaps the _parables_ are claiming that the ghost he is ... What rickety boat? That metaphor jumps away from the piece, for me, in a very confusing way. I really like "but stricken [...] strikes back". Screaming for help, sinking like a stone? What do you see?
Wakeboarder20 replying on Peter by Wakeboarder20 5 Oct 2006, 10:22 AM
It may be a little clearer now.
Wakeboarder20 replying on Peter by Wakeboarder20 5 Oct 2006, 10:21 AM
Thanks for the suggestions. This is not the final form of this poem so I'll consider what you said when I revise it.
Dovina on Peter by Wakeboarder20 5 Oct 2006, 10:08 AM
It's better in the edit. "What I never knew I could do but did all the same." A good take on the story. This could use some tightening, some elimination of sidetracks. For example, the reference to parables and the unknown is really another issue, isn't it? And the boat was probably not rickety; these were professional fishermen, after all.
Wakeboarder20 replying on Peter by Wakeboarder20 5 Oct 2006, 8:56 AM
The boat metaphor cane from the story of Jesus walking on water. According to the Bible, Jesus walked on water out to a fishing boat in the middle of a storm. Peter happened to be on that boat and asked Jesus to ask him to follow and Jesus did. So Peter got off of the boat and started to walk on water. But he began to lose faith (either in himself or Jesus, it's up to the reader to figure that out) and he began to sink. He called out to Jesus to save him and Jesus did and then asked him why he would doubt.
Dovina on Innocence revisited by Caducus 5 Oct 2006, 7:36 AM
I read "wasted on from desire" as "wasted on desire." Go figure. And try "virginal body yard." Hey, it beats "vaginal."
Dovina replying on Street Preacher by Dovina 5 Oct 2006, 7:28 AM
Welcome back. Hey, I won't dream of throwing up a "why."
Shuushin on Death by rabbit by INTRANSIT 5 Oct 2006, 7:16 AM
I think "black maw" doesn't help things, but otherwise very well crafted.
The action is well described, as is the projectile's intent - but the imagery is primitive.
Shuushin on 9/11/2001 by MuDvAyNe 5 Oct 2006, 7:10 AM
me no comprenday.
Shuushin on Upon the Battlefield by cleverdevice 5 Oct 2006, 4:22 AM
killed by a strife/life rhyme. Nobody uses the word strife and expects not to be eaten by bed-monsters, not even Frances Cornford.
Shuushin on Surreal... by Yardbird 5 Oct 2006, 4:20 AM
insane. Funny.
Shuushin on Peter by Wakeboarder20 5 Oct 2006, 4:19 AM
The boat metaphor comes out of nowhere, but otherwise I like the tone. Fairly cogent, too. Apply some poetic tools and it could find a wider appeal.
Shuushin on Slow death by Blade 5 Oct 2006, 4:16 AM
A slow death? More like a day in the life!
harryparatestes on untitled by harryparatestes 5 Oct 2006, 3:13 AM
srry netwined for deleting your comment i tryed to reply first if you read my other comment im new to this the only form of poetry i know is haiku and i dont remember if thats 5-7-5 or not i have no idea what a pimple is besides a zit the only poetry ive read is dr. suess so forgive me if i have no idea what your talking about
Fugazi on The Sleep Fantastic by nentwined 5 Oct 2006, 12:44 AM
Be interested to see which dictionary holds the word zombiehood, as I can't seem to find it anywhere, apart from that .. interesting.
Wakeboarder20 on Peter by Wakeboarder20 4 Oct 2006, 11:06 PM
Well, I revised the poem again. Now it's nothing like it was before. I had reread the story about Jesus walking on the water to a group of fishermen and peter walking out to Jesus. I wanted to do something with that story but couldn't think of what. Right now it's just a straight re-telling of the story. I'm going to try to think of what I can do to change it a little and get some message across.
Shuushin on Untitled by PunkyPanda 4 Oct 2006, 6:59 PM
a scab implies a healing wound, no? I'd like to see this said with fewer, more powerful imagery.