Christof
replying on "REAL" People by Scouser
20 Sep 2002, 5:55 AM
Thank you for saying that... I was going to earlier but didn't want to look like a Yank-basher. God knows Britain has a pretty murky history as well, but we were never in a position to devastate the entire planet. With power comes responsibility and all that (wasn't that in Spiderman?)
this is really good. i'm kinda confused, but that's ok, the poem has that feeling through out and it works. good job!t
You're right that it's worth pursuing, it is an interesting project. But I do believe that poetry should always remember that it comes, at source, from an oral tradition, the rhythmic use of language to plant concepts and images into a culture, and that poetry that makes no concession to the ear is going to be hard going. There doesn't have to be a strict metre, but a speech rhythm helps and this poem has the rhythm of a cut-up essay - it doesn't help to bring the reader into your ideas but acts as an obstacle. I wouldn't read a politics essay for pleasure, but I would read a good political poem for pleasure. But there's no reason why your idea shouldn't work with further refinement. Your 'Glamorgan' poem shows that you have very strong speech rhythms in you.
Mate .....Its not a poem,but a piece of prose .You have arranged lines & sreamed thoughts to fit a form. Ideas images are not encouraged. It has plenty of potential but no challenge.
Maybe it isn't poetry, but then I don't liking making judgements about what poetry is and what it should deal with. Poetry can do anything. Even rhythm isn't always required. Anything can be fashioned into poetry, and the point is to use discourses that are all around us and turn them into art - just as some people utilise working class language or slang, I'm trying to use the language of the media, the dominant discourse in modern western life, and make something out of it. Perhaps it doesn't work, but I think it is an idea worth pursuing.
P&K, love the gulls. Birds rock don't they? I like this poem, sesnually it's very strong.
I love the fact that I wrote a political poem and it brought forth torrents of xenophobia and even a little homophobia - not quite sure where that came from. Have any of you people heard of irony? Or the dramatic monologue - the narrator of a poem is not always the author. By the way, more people were killed by US bombing than died on September 11. And 9,000 people die of AIDS each day, the majority in sub-Saharan Africa. Pup that in your pipe and smoke it.
Take the paracetamol, you'll feel better
Here is someone who truly wants to be anonymous, describing themselves as "Hi!! I just turned 6 and I write poetry. My mommy and daddy love my work and
say I am the next Robert Lowell. I don't know who that is or anything but they
told me about this site and I wanted to share my writing and poetry with the
world. I have a best friend and I love to play with my dog and eat happy meals.
I am a Christian, SWM who loves to chat after mommy and daddy go to bed.
Please do not be to mean to my poems. Please. Pretty please. "
With a mouth like that, I you must be some Christian
you like AIDS? total crap
Because you did not like the poem gives you no right to slate the workings of another. comment, but don't lose it. this style is appreciated by some, but not toerhs. Constructive comments work better then plain nastiness. Stop being inconsiderate and if you do not like it that much, don't post.
Nicholas I hope you didn't mind me using your poem as a springboard for a lecture. sorry!
Hang on old boy, Mr Jones doesn't speak for me or for England. Anyway, he's Welsh. Very different. However, I'm not sure if, as someone suggested before, Britain actually is responsible for the Afghanistan problem. One thing Britain can't be blamed for is the US arming and training rebels (who despised America all along) against the Soviet Union, keeping the seat nice and warm for the Taliban and then being surprised when they decided to use those same weapons against them. Make a pact with the devil and you will pay for it with your soul. Yes the English Empire made a lot of mistakes in the past, but some Americans should think more carefully before laying responsibility for all the world's problems at our door, which always seems to happen when the word 'Imperialism' comes up - because you plainly haven't learnt from our example and are making the same mistakes. But this time, with enough weaponry to destroy the planet. So yes, let's all think a bit more carefully before invading other countries without international support, because unilateral action by US and UK will be disastrous.
This Press Conference is now over. Good day gentlemen.
I'm afraid I agree with Tintagiles. You also put a lot of thought into your poems and debate crucial issues, but sometimes you forget to put it into poetic form - there's no rhythm here, unlike your 'Glamorgan' poem.
This is great - the first stanza really kicks it off, I like the dig at the Eisteddfod's 'authenticity' and your very realistic view of Wales. And there is hope at the end. Definitely your best yet.