Dovina
on TO MY SON on his 25th birthday by outdoorzylady
30 Jul 2006, 3:59 PM
I like the straightforward, no nonsense, presentation. While some may complain of poetic negligence, sincerity is there. For that Iâd give a 10. But since the poetry, for what little poetic excellence is really worth, is worth only a 5 in my opinion, have an 8. And enjoy your son.
One of many Bush-war-slams these days. The unusual thing about this one is "chemical weapons." Just how do you mean that?
it's about collection and building, the use and building of credit, platforms for understanding and conceptualizing people, relationships, items, existence, how thought thin they are (fickle and easily burned), so urgent and necessary (like tuesday and thursday), it gets personal
Why, was that too much for you to understand in one reading?
I wish I could figure this out. It sounds like it might be interesting.
Perhaps you could sum it up with âsupercilious.â Just a thought.
Hmm, well I don't want to sound rude but this has been done a million times before, mostly on poemranker. Seriously, the 'loneliness-pain-death' theme could not be more overused. If you do think it's a subject you want to write about then please please please find a more original way of saying it. Have a read around poemranker, 50% of the poems on here contain more or less the same content as this, and that makes it boring for those few of us who actually read what's posted. If you really want to grab the reader's attention, give them something unique, clever and surprising.
Read through a few dozen of the poems here in the lower half, note the recurring themes/phrases/words and avoid them at all costs. I'm not joking - count how many other pieces contain 'tears', 'loneliness', 'heart', 'pain', 'hurt' and 'fear'. You'll see what I mean; after reading a few they all start to blend into one and aren't interesting. Or if you don't want to read through all those poems, read the definition of 'pimple poem' given on the ranker.
I hope this is ultimately of some use to you with your writing.
some deleted user
on Cupid Missed Two Junkies (slightly clearer, rambling draft) by Ranger
29 Jul 2006, 12:40 PM
Cupid ... I've seen countless poems about Cupid. This is not by far the most original.
Potential, potential ... but not quite there.
You take the meaning of "free verse" to a whole new level, and I don't mean that as a compliment.
Maybe someone would start caring if you changed your soddy attitude. I've seen comments that you've left on others' poems, and they were RUDE to put it mildy. My previous comments were left to teach you a lesson. It's not nice when you put effort into writing something, only to have someone else come tell you how unoriginal it is and how bad it is, when in fact this person is a far better writer than you ever have hope of being. For the record, she's been published more than just a few times ... have you ??? Learn your lesson in manners, child. Grow up and start being NICE to others for a change; would it kill you?????
You really need to work on your grammar.
This has the potential to be an incredibly good write. It just wasn't, though. I see below comments that you're trying to explain the poem; if you need to do that that's when you really know that it was a bad write. Maybe stick to writing about things more personal and therefore more readable. Poetry is supposed to be FELT ... yet I felt nothing when I read this.
Topics like this are sooooo overdone. I feel lack of originality here. Have you run out of ideas to write on?
I like the blare/Blair inuendo, if it is one - works for me. The "eons come undone" line reads as if some new thing is going on - new ways of doing it maybe. The thousand rockets equation to a thousand hopes makes it look like every rocket kills a hope, which is far from true. "past it's masters' keeping" shows the crude technology, and the rest shows how it is working.
Thanks for the good comments. I've revised it again. But I am so in love with the verisimilitude line, it has to stay. The way I see the diary, it is a collection of symbols and representations of the truth about what really happened. So it is not fact, but something near fact. And as I look back at it, some is ridiculously far from fact.
Some great details in this. "scene from a perfect haiku" seems too obvious. Second verse is my favorite.