poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 8081–8100 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

Ranger replying on my girl's day [tri-ku] by lmp 17 Apr 2006, 11:45 PM
It works better, although the second line of that stanza is a syllable over. Perhaps 'She runs, her shadow shortens'. That would also eliminate the repetition of 'as'. I wouldn't change any of the imagery in there, it works beautifully, and with the shadow you manage to capture the middle of the day without being unnecessarily explicit and wordy. Suggestion for you to play with as you see fit: 'Watercolour laugh' - if you were thinking of changing the last line of stanza 2. It would fit with 'She runs', and would augment the 'lightness' of the piece. Just a thought though, you may not feel it's necessary. Vote moved up to 9.
Ranger on Sunlighting by ALChemy 17 Apr 2006, 11:30 PM
Why have I not read this one before? It's gorgeous. Killer final line.
Ranger on slice of moonlight by lmp 17 Apr 2006, 11:25 PM
'Stabile' jarred, the rest is wonderful.
Dovina on slice of moonlight by lmp 17 Apr 2006, 4:55 PM
Good use of the Terza Rima rhyme scheme, without seeming forced.
ecargo on jay by ecargo 17 Apr 2006, 1:54 PM
Math poem fans: "Gregory K. Pincus, a screenwriter and aspiring children's book author . . . wrote a post on his GottaBook blog (gottabook.blogspot.com) two weeks ago inviting readers to write "Fibs," six-line poems that used a mathematical progression known as the Fibonacci sequence to dictate the number of syllables in each line. Then, last Friday, . . . slashdot.org . . . linked to Mr. Pincus's original post, and suddenly, it seemed, Fibs were sprouting all over the Internet." Story here: http://www.nytimes.com/2006/04/14/books/14fibo.html?ex=1145419200&en=e0ccb44acd92493d&ei=5087%0A
ecargo on jay by ecargo 17 Apr 2006, 1:50 PM
Pulitzer (announced today) for poetry goes to Claudia Emerson for _Late Wife,_ - "Epistolary poems about losing love and finding it again." http://www.nytimes.com/ref/arts/pulitzers2006.html (registration required) Three poems by Emerson for anyone curious about what Pulitzer Prize winning poetry looks like: http://www.poems.com/threeeme.htm
richa on Lovely Independence by Sunny 17 Apr 2006, 12:25 PM
The last line is a bit tame. I like the enjambment in the main, my mood/changes especially.
What? No votes? Even beardless and guntless, very funny (though not as funny as a "cream-horne of Jesu"--but what is?). I used "gunt" (the word, not the unsightly appendage) in conversation the other day.
ecargo on greymo(u)rn by lmp 17 Apr 2006, 11:37 AM
Nicely descriptive, and the lack of narrative (story, whatever) is fine, but while reading it I kept reaching for more of a--well, not a point, exactly, but some sort of earlier payoff. The point seems to be the longing, and I think the last stanza gets there (to that payoff point), but the lead-up is a little too scene-setty for me. I think less of a linear approach might work, e.g., starting off with "it was better before the fog burned off; at least the mystery of what may be hidden within was appealing." The usual disclaimers here.
Dovina replying on In Ethel’s Honor by Dovina 17 Apr 2006, 8:01 AM
In his mind, he watched her - thought of her when she was alive. Thanks.
Dovina replying on In Ethel’s Honor by Dovina 17 Apr 2006, 7:58 AM
“Winding rain” does imply wind, as the rain winds its way at an angle. The 61 years are for specificity, but maybe that’s not needed. The thing I want to show in his perseverance and that he always did what he could.
Dovina replying on In Ethel’s Honor by Dovina 17 Apr 2006, 7:56 AM
I agree that explanations are like male nipples if they are not contained in the poem. But anyway, the “trunk” is the trunk of his car. And, he nailed the flower pot to the ground by pounding a chopstick down through its bottom. It actually worked pretty well.
ecargo on In Ethel’s Honor by Dovina 17 Apr 2006, 7:53 AM
Simple and vivid=good. "Then watched her" in the second verse is a little confusing.
ecargo on Another quarter. by richa 17 Apr 2006, 7:49 AM
Other than "scalding" and the pie, ace in my book. Simple in all the best of ways.
ecargo on Skellington Bakery by -=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. 17 Apr 2006, 7:48 AM
A yummy cautionary poeme--most light and flaky (like the fabled Cream-horne of Jesu, I imagine). The footnotes were the cherry on the treat.
Dovina on Lovely Independence by Sunny 17 Apr 2006, 7:39 AM
The enjambed verses don't work for me. You can do that, but only if a new thought begins in the new verse. I think you mean botching.
Dovina replying on Another quarter. by richa 17 Apr 2006, 7:31 AM
Maybe it rides over the sticks.
Dovina on Another quarter. by richa 17 Apr 2006, 7:30 AM
Some good connections: scalding frost, cuts like a cigar. scend gone like a left-out pie. Spring sprung. Good.
lmp replying on my girl's day [tri-ku] by lmp 17 Apr 2006, 7:18 AM
ah yes. well sometimes i do wonder myself. so i guess the duality is real. don't believe that she does knows about knights yet, so that one *is* a stretch... thanks for the comments.
INTRANSIT on Another quarter. by richa 17 Apr 2006, 6:12 AM
rides (comma) sticks? and cuts/clips? thst's it for my nits.