zodiac
on Quiet Hands by Sunny
30 Mar 2006, 1:42 PM
Clocks should almost never be used in poetry. Especially not as symbols of time stopping or moving on.
Yes, a very smooth edit. It works much better as a piece of prose. I feel that maybe in a couple of places you'd do well to add in an occasional shorter sentence to link the longer passages together a little more clearly; but see how other people read this first. Also, you could seperate the last bit from the rest:
'...the regulars left their tips
And he ordered himself his first drink.'
This is sweet. I would delete the word "me" almost every time it appears, though.
zodiac
on Behind the storm clouds, the moon consoles the sun.(edited) by ALChemy
30 Mar 2006, 1:38 PM
Blake.
I would only change "You make my day" to something a little more original. Otherwise, it's happy and very sweet. I'm glad you're experimenting with different types of poetry!
I like this alot but the last line seems like it's just a filler. Everything else is so personal and sincere that the last line with it's cliche`ness comes across like a Halmark card. Maybe something like "Is as surely as your distance grows".
You're not from Tennesee?
When I started reading the first few lines with their long sentenced rhyme scheme it reminded me of Benny Hill.
Maybe this will give you some ideas for lightening your poem up.
http://www.lyricsplayground.com/alpha/so ngs/e/erniethefastestmilkmaninthewest.sht ml
You might have to copy and paste, it's a long url.
Niphredil got it spot on by suggesting you don't repeat words (not so soon, anyway). I also found it interesting that the first stanza could be put directly in front of the last, and with the addition of a little punctuation it would work nicely. I'd love to see if you could apply this to the whole poem; work it so that any stanza could lead straight into any other.
I found the line breaks a little disruptive, but that could easily just be my way of reading it.
I think I liked your 'fishy' poem better. This seems a bit disconnected on the whole and I wasn't really impressed compared to quite a few writes of yours. Probably you aught ot edit it , although I don't know exactly how. I'm still not clear on what you had in mind while writing this.
Beautiful, one too many 'loves' though, maybe replace the second one with something else. Other than that, I'm not going to complain about something as sweet as this.
Smoothly done, violent like a game. The imagery is very strong (as with most of your stuff, come to think of it!)
Cool!
drnick and ecargo.... I hope you find this a good change. Enjoy!
'Her saddest smile...' got me going, I feel there's more waiting to be said from there. However, I also think it would spoil the swift beauty of this one. I really like the brevity of it, although I'm not convinced by the first two lines. Still a very pleasant read.
Cool stuff, I thought the first line of stanza 2 was a bit unoriginal and didn't quite fit with the rest of that stanza. I like the rhyme scheme and the quick rhythm of it. 'My mind cannot fathom even in post-graduate fashion' is a smart line.
I actually think the last stanza might just about hold up...but ecargo is right that it doesn't sound right when read.